Showing posts with label Leonardo da Vinci. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Leonardo da Vinci. Show all posts

29 June 2020

JUST HORSING AROUND: "THE COLOSSUS OF LEONARDO DA VINCI" COURTESY OF EUROPEANA

Exhibition Reviews | Madison Carmichael


I don’t know about you, but an unfinished project haunts me like little else. One has to wonder if Leonardo da Vinci felt the same about his never-completed equestrian monument of Francesco Sforza. Luckily for us, the reams of notes and drawings of said monument remain, preserved by the National Library of Spain, so a virtual reconstruction of Leonardo’s design and casting process is now possible. The story of the unfinished equestrian bronze comprises “The Colossus of Leonardo da Vinci,” a special online exhibition produced by Europeana, in collaboration with the National Library of Spain and the Museo Galileo

Armed with Leonardo’s original notes and drawings, experts from Florence’s Museo Galileo sought to marry his original manuscripts to new digital reconstructions so as to finally build the bronze that was never built – or else to bring it to life as best they could, with the technology available to us now. 

The title page of the online exhibition. This functions largely like the introductory panel, but it also gives a sneak peek at one of Leonardo's designs. (Source)
Much like I mentioned last month, online and digital exhibitions ask that you create your own atmosphere. While my current residence is not nearly as chaotic as it was, I once again headed over to YouTube to see what I could find in terms of ambiance and soundscapes (here are a few). 

“The Colossus of Leonardo da Vinci” has seven chapters: the protagonists, two concepts for the statue, an innovative moulding process, a multi-furnace foundry, two different casting methods, the project is abandoned, and modern evocations. This chaptered approach guides you through Leonardo’s design and engineering process, the events that led to the project’s abandonment (an invasion, which necessitated that the bronze set aside for the monument be used to cast artillery instead, followed by an occupation and subsequent fall of the Sforzas), and modern evocations of the monument.

A portrait of Galeazzo Maria Sforza found within the exhibition. He was the original patron of the project. (Source)
In its structure, “The Colossus of Leonardo da Vinci” straddles the past and the present. The exhibition begins in the late 1400s, when the Duke of Milan, Galeazzo Maria Sforza, conceived of an equestrian monument to celebrate his dynasty. The project was propelled by his successor, and when Leonardo received the commission for this project, he proceeded to absolutely run away with it. In perhaps a characteristic move, Leonardo transformed the commission into an “epic undertaking,” one that was entirely unheard of in both the history of art and in the scope of casting methods, as he set out to produce this enormous, equestrian monument – I say enormous, because this monument would require more than sixty tons of bronze and would stand over seven metres tall – in a single cast. 

From here, the exhibition moves through the two concept designs for the monument – a rider on a prancing horse vs. a walking horse – the moulding process, which was enormously complex, the foundry Leonardo envisioned for the casting process, and two different casting processes that he considered.

This 3D reconstruction renders the vertical foundry system which comprised of one of Leonardo's concepts for casting. It was done by Andrea Bernadoni and Riccardo Braga of the Museo Galileo. (Source)

This image depict the original drawings as done by Leonardo, conceptualizing a foundry to cast the horse. Compare it to the 3D rendering above! (Source)
This exhibition takes an enormously interdisciplinary approach to one, unfinished project of Leonardo da Vinci’s. It is at times historical, or art historical, and at others it is deeply technical, drawing on technological design and renderings. As someone deeply interested in the historical contexts of most things, I found it fascinating to peer into this specific moment in time, and the events surrounding it, and to learn through Leonardo’s notes and drawings more about the technology of the 1400s and about how, even hypothetically, a monument may have been cast at this point in time. 

As mentioned, what’s interesting about this exhibition is how it ties the historical to the present – how it straddles the past and the present. This is most evident in the images interspersed throughout. In the chapters detailing the design and engineering process, modern 3D reconstructions are displayed alongside the historical equivalents done by Leonardo. It is in this way that this exhibition endeavors to bring this unfinished monument to life, using the tools we now have in concert with the plans Leonardo left behind.

Two modern evocations of this very project exist worldwide! (Source)
The exhibition closes with two modern evocations, or realizations, of Leonardo’s unfinished monument. One was completed under the direction of Hidemichi Tanaka, which was unveiled in 1989 in Nagoya City, Japan. The other was completed by American artist Nina Akamu, which was inaugurated in Milan in 1999, and it can still be found in front of the hippodrome of San Siro. 

There’s something poetic in that, I think. While neither of these modern projects were developed using the casting techniques that Leonardo penned just about five hundred years ago, they were both completed regardless. Add to that the 3D reconstructions completed by the Museo Galileo that do portray his techniques, it makes me feel like his unfinished monument has been finished, in a way. 

After all, a bronze, equestrian monument does stand in Milan, at what was ostensibly the planned site of Leonardo’s original horse. So, perhaps we have indeed brought this unfinished project to life, as best as we are able. 

29 November 2018

DEBATING THE AUTHENTICITY OF RESTORATION

Conservation Tips & Tricks | Selin Kahramanoglu

Welcome to the second article of my three-part series about different conservation methods! This week, I will discuss restoration practices, and use a recently reworked famous Italian painting as our case study. Cominciano!

The Last Supper, by Leonardo da Vinci, found at Santa Maria delle Grazie in Milan. Source.
What's the story?

According to a report by The Independent in 2012, The Last Supper was restored out of Leonardo da Vinci's modern studio, by Pinin Brambilla Barcilon and Pietro Marani. The painting had particular damage from grime and also suffered from bad restoration techniques in the past. In 1999, the artwork was finally revealed after twenty years of conservation efforts, but not everyone was pleased.

In situ, the 1498 painting is located on the wall of the Santa Maria delle Grazie in Milan. In true Leonardo da Vinci fashion, the tempera painting is on top of sealed stone, which is prone to discolouration and deterioration, especially when exposed to humid climates overtime. However, some people think that the recent restoration overwhelms the painting, and the original work is barely present. People start asking the question: Is it even a Leonardo da Vinci anymore?

Why bother with restoration?

As mentioned in my previous article of this series, humidity is a major threat to historical artifacts and sites! In this case, there were only two options: 1) The conservators intervene and restore the painting, or 2) The painting continues to deteriorate naturally. What do we do when it comes to an original Leonardo da Vinci masterpiece? Most conservators will choose to rescue it.

The choice to restore a piece of history is not an easy one. For The Last Supper, there isn't much to think about, because the painting was produced from a famous artist. It is culturally valuable, and thus deserves conservation efforts. Yet, other artifacts are not so smussato - for example, some pieces may be ancient and historically interesting, but not too publicized, and often overlooked by the general public. Both scholars and the average person needs to be able to find the object culturally important, so that the artifact is worth the money, labour, and resources for conservation.

Focus on the good!

Apart from saving an artifact from completely disappearing off the face of the earth, restoration is useful for two related reasons: First, a restored piece gives the impression that it is one "whole." From the outside, a good restoration job means that you can't tell between the original and the recent reworkings. The artifact gives the illusion that it has not been slowly deteriorating, but instead seems visually complete and untouched. Molto bene!

Second, a restored artifact (especially a Leonardo da Vinci work) attracts tourists. It is the same idea when something new and sparkly comes on display at a jewelry store. When a historical objects comes out of storage for the first time in years, the public wants to see it - in its entirety. Speaking from experience, visitors don't typically enjoy seeing a tiny fragment of an object, while the rest of the item is lost, or fading to dust.

We can't ignore the bad...

Restoration involves intervention. In my opinion, the moment you alter an artifact, it is no longer 100% original. The Last Supper, for example, is still an authentic work, but the object's identity now has an added layer. Despite efforts to replicate the item as smooth and exact as possible, the object's biography changes, and we add a chapter of restoration to its history. 

Not only this, restoration resources are expensive, difficult to acquire, and need advanced expertise - not the easiest to come by! Mi dispiace, but you need a large amount of funding and support to get a restoration project approved and completed. Moreover, in the past, a bad restoration job is often met with a fierce public outcry and have not always been fixable.


I'll leave the decision up to you! Which do you prefer, restoration or natural deterioration? It's a bit of a debate among conservators, but one thing is for sure - as long as the conservation technique is reversible without causing damage, why not give it a try? Arrivederci amici!

Additional References