Showing posts with label Galleries. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Galleries. Show all posts

18 February 2020

YOU MUST BE THIS OLD TO VISIT: CHILDREN IN GALLERIES & MUSEUMS

GLAM Guide | Madison Carmichael

Every once in a while, I’m struck by how I behave in museums. I walk silently, with my arms tucked tight behind my back – as though if I don’t contain myself, a rogue arm might lash out and damage something precious and priceless. I visit museums and galleries with my colleagues here at the faculty, and I notice them doing it too: ghosting through galleries without a sound, hands trapped against their sides, arms firmly crossed. 

I don’t remember how, or when, or where I was taught that this is how one comports oneself in a museum. In all likelihood it was at some point in my late childhood. And so I wonder if this is the threshold for adulthood in the museum world: adults know the rules and rigidly adhere to them, whereas children do not.

The Tate Modern. (Source)
Does this then mean that children shouldn’t visit museums and galleries? Folks in the GLAM sector have been tossing this question around since 2014, when two children climbed up onto a Donald Judd sculpture at the Tate Modern.  In the press, this event has been listed alongside incidents at museums that resulted in toppled statues, defeathered animal specimens, and ripped paintings, illuminating the potential dangers posed to collections on display. But more significantly, the incident at the Tate Modern – tweeted out to the world by the outraged New York gallery owner who witnessed it – instigated a heated debate that demanded, with unforgiving language, whether children should be banned from museums.
Donald Judd's "Untitled," 1980: the sculpture in question. (Source)
The very notion seems antithetical to ongoing efforts to open up the GLAM sector to wider audiences, and it operates in direct opposition to what researchers have been advocating for the past few decades: that museums ought to increase the attention paid to our younger audiences. In an article for the BBC, Michelle Warwicker rather critically stated that “art galleries are no longer places of reverent observation and hushed whispers.” The Metropolitan Museum of Art and (interestingly) the Tate Modern offer child-friendly exhibits and activities. Leigh-Anne Stradeski, Chief Executive at Eureka! The National Children’s Museum, concurs. She argues that the increase in child and family-friendly content is driven by changing public expectations regarding the role of museums in our lives as well as the more practical concern of attracting new audiences in the face of funding issues. In her opinion, “it can only be a good thing that museums have become more accessible to children, families, and other diverse audiences.” 

Not everyone agrees.

The first children's museum was opened in 1899, in Brookyn. Children's museums have flourished since as an alternative for parents and kids. Eureka! opened in the UK, in 1985, and it was modeled off its American counterparts. (Source)
There is a loud, oft-repeated assertion that children don’t “get” art. British artist Jake Chapman went one step further and declared that assuming that a child could understand complex works was both “arrogance” and “insult.” In his view, to insinuate that a child could understand art was to imply that “it’s as moronic as a child.” 

As I said, there seems to be a threshold for adulthood in the museum. Behaviour certainly informs that particular convention, but so too does how we interact with art. But unlike many of us grown-ups, children possess no uneasy need to “get” art. Where we are uncertain, they are open-minded and spontaneous in how they respond to and interpret works. They simply need a little more support to do so. Katrina Weier explains that children as ably pick favourites among artworks and relate them to their own experiences as any adult would. In 2004 – a decade before the incident at the Tate Modern and Chapman’s remarks – the Ipswich Art Gallery (formerly the Global Arts Link) led a program wherein children led a tour for a familiar adult. They discussed their favourite objects with varying degrees of detail, gave descriptions, and explained why they liked the objects.


What Weier’s study reveals is that children possess a capacity to talk about art. They become engaged interpreters when they feel that they can access the art in their own way and in their own words. And isn’t that how adults too are encouraged to “get” art?

We’re often told that art galleries in particular are places for looking, for doing so quietly. Children in the museum loudly disrupt the ritual of museum-going to which we are accustomed, and I think that this may be what we intimidated and unsure adults need. Warwicker notes that adults “may just have to learn to share exhibition space with these unpredictable little visitors” with some resignation, but even she admits that their natural curiosity can be infectious. And when we witness how willing they are to engage without fear of being wrong, they give us permission to do the same.

Museums of art tend to intimidate adult visitors. What if we embraced the unrestrained curiosity of children? (Source) 
As for the risks of children running in museums and galleries, it’s worth noting that most accidental damage to collections is caused by adults, not children. In the case of the Judd sculpture at the Tate Modern, however, I think Stradeski says it best: 

“If a child sees a climbing frame where an adult sees a priceless piece of art it's a matter of perspective - and if that poses a problem, the onus is on the professionals to facilitate the child's interpretation and experience of the sculpture." (Stradeski) 

Kids are kids. They aren’t little adults, so we shouldn’t expect them to be. But in our capacity as museum staff, educators, parents, etcetera, it’s up to us to facilitate how a child engages in the museum space. The answer to the challenge of children cannot be to close our doors on them. If we work to understand and support children’s visits, engaging the adults who accompany them, we not only provide them with a shared, meaningful experience; in a way, we ensure the future of the GLAM sector writ large. 

24 January 2020

RECOGNIZING OURSELVES: PLACE & RELEVANCE AT THE TOM THOMSON ART GALLERY


In a delightfully titled article about the Owen Sound and North Grey Union Public Library (“Having fun isn’t hard when you have a library card,” if you’re curious), Andy Elliott urges his reader to not only come and enjoy the library, but to also visit the adjoining Tom Thomson Art Gallery (TOM). He urges the reader: “you can see some of the best art Canada has ever produced, and it’s all right here in our little community.” Needless to say, I was intrigued.

The Owen Sound Public Library. Photo courtesy of Madison Carmichael.

The Tom Thomson Art Gallery. The piece atop the building reads: "I feel the thing is of too great an importance to miss." Photo courtesy of Madison Carmichael. 
The TOM was established to memorialize Canadian artist Tom Thomson – a significant inspiration for the Group of Seven – who grew up in Leith, a town situated on the shores of Georgian Bay just north of Owen Sound. The TOM features numerous works by not only Tom Thomson, but also several members of the Group of Seven. Currently, they keep works by Tom Thomson, as well as his oil sketches and other archival materials, on permanent display, but they also host several temporary exhibitions, one of which really resonated with me during my visit – Footprints in Time: Painting around Georgian Bay. 

Mr. Thomson himself. Photo courtesy of Madison Carmichael. 


I should first confess that I’m not from Owen Sound, but over the past few years, I’ve spent more and more time in Bruce and Grey Counties, neighbouring regions sandwiched between Lake Huron and Georgian Bay. So, when I went to see Footprints in Time just after the new year, I was completely unaware of the rich backstory of this exhibition. Unbeknownst to me, this exhibition was the result of a moment of crisis for the TOM.

In 2017, the TOM experienced a significant financial deficit. According to city officials, the gallery had a large budgetary shortfall. Costs were cut, staff levels were reduced, and the chief object of leadership moving forward to devise less expensive ways to put on exhibitions.

The gallery catalogue for the exhibition, which contains essays from Katharine Lochnan and Louise Moore. Photo courtesy of Madison Carmichael 
As a result, Footprints in Time was the work of volunteer-based curatorship. Community curators were invited to create shows for the TOM from the gallery’s expansive permanent collection, which contained many pieces that had never been shown due to limitations in both space and funding. Among them were Katharine Lochnan – senior curator emeritus for the AGO and long-time resident of the region – Louise Moore and local art historian Judith Thomson. It was the latter who, with a deep familiarity with the collection, suggested that they create an imaginary tour around Georgian Bay through the curation of site-specific works or those they knew would represent the area. 

Footprints in Time, therefore, draws inspiration and meaning from place. The art on display is inextricably tied to the Georgian Bay region, as are the artists as well, for most all of the artists featured in the exhibition called this region home at some point in their lives.

Sydenham River, Owen Sound (date unknown), by George Thomson. Elder brother of Tom Thomson, George painted several scenes from the region over the course of his career. Photo courtesy of Madison Carmichael. 
Water Spirits (1975), by Daphne Odjig. Odjig was born on Manitoulin Island in 1919 and is one of several Indigenous artists shown in this exhibition, including Blake Debassige, Joshim Kakegamic, and Norval Morrisseau. Photo courtesy of Madison Carmichael.
More than that, the exhibition is grounded in the gallery itself. The exhibition contains 45 works from the gallery’s permanent collection, and the permanent collection alone, many of which they have never exhibited before. Footprints in Time is, then, not only an imaginary tour of Georgian Bay; it is a very real tour of the gallery’s expansive collection and of the rich artistic tradition in the region.

All of this is to say that this exhibition was incredibly relevant to its context. When we discuss interpretation and meaning-making in the GLAM sector, it is underlined by the belief that it is easier for us to make meaningful connections to something we can relate to. Relevant museums are therefore meaningful museums. Lon Dubinsky states that social relevance is tied to how the museum functions as a place. It has much to do with the proximity of museums to individuals – both physically and psychologically. Jane K. Nielson takes a similar tact by defining relevance in museological practices. She argues that relevance is centered on what is directly connected to practical aspects of a subject; crucially, she states that it can also be very individual. What is relevant to me might not be relevant to you. 

A collection of paintings from the exhibition. Among them: George Thomson, Charles Finley, Tom Thomson, and Florence Campbell. Photograph courtesy of Madison Carmichael.
In her essay in the gallery catalogue, Louise Moore tells us that landscapes of places known provide comfort to their viewer, as well as sense of stability in their environment. Most critical to my reflection here – and to the title of this article – she remarks that “we recognize the landscape and we recognize ourselves.” The landscapes on display offer something familiar, and in doing so, they work to affirm a sense of home and of place for those who are versed in the imagery shown. For whom it is relevant. 

At its core, Footprints in Time isn’t just about the place on display; it’s about how this place operates as a home for those who live within it. This may not be a ground-breaking theme, but I would argue that while it doesn’t break ground, per se, it certainly grounds you. And if we’re talking about relevancy within GLAM institutions, I’d say that in the case of the TOM, this was a powerful tact to take. 

There is, then, significant strength to grounding an exhibition in its locality. In my opinion, the unique facet of local museums and galleries is that they are oftentimes inextricably tied to their locality; their chief object must be to remain relevant to those communities. The TOM certainly succeeded here, offering an exhibition in which visitors could see both themselves and their home. The exhibition was meant to have closed on January 5th, 2020, but it’s been extended through to the end of February due to its popularity.
"Relevant museums are therefore meaningful museums."

Another collection of paintings from the exhibition. Among them: A.Y. Jackson, Arthur Lismer, and Illingworth Kerr. Photo courtesy of Madison Carmichael. 
As I mentioned, the Georgian Bay region is not home to me in the same way it was (and is) to the artists featured here. But it has certainly become familiar. When I left the gallery and made my way out from Owen Sound proper, I caught sight of 9th Street.

Roly Fenwick’s “9th Street West.” It depicts the northern entrance to Owen Sound, where he was born and grew up. Photo courtesy of Madison Carmichael.  
I thought immediately of this painting. I looked at it from the opposite angle, but I recognized the slope of the street, the rock rising on both sides, and the trees lining it. Moore was right. In my recognition of this landscape, I felt a sense of comfort; and I felt a sense of connection not only to Owen Sound but to the TOM itself. 

That feeling stuck with me the whole way home. 

24 October 2019

OPEN UP: ACCESS, EXPERIENCE, & PARTICIPATION IN THE GLAM SECTOR


GLAM Guide | Madison Carmichael


In his presentation at re:publica 2019, the thirteenth edition of that conference, Douglas McCarthy centered his keynote talk around the following quote from the American judge and legal philosopher Learned Hand: 

“The spirit of liberty is the spirit which is not too sure that it is right...it seeks to understand the minds of other men and women.” (Learned Hand, 1872-1961)

He tells us that in this quote is a humility that he would like to see more of in the museum sector, though I’d argue that it’s applicable to the GLAM sector writ large. Certainly, there is a beautiful sort of freedom in the admittance of I don’t know. When we don’t know something, we reach out. We ask questions. And when others answer, hopefully we listen. 

McCarthy goes on to say that museums should embrace “a confident but unsure listening mode.” The time is past for top-down dictation to the public. There’s been a shift in how people interact with GLAM content and with the institutions themselves, so we’re faced with a more participatory reality, and the challenge for the GLAM sector, McCarthy says, lies in embracing it.  

So, it’s time for the GLAM sector to open up. Or, to continue opening up. This includes both opening the GLAM mindset to experiences that are immersive and innovative and opening the sector’s extensive collections to the public. It means re-establishing GLAM institutions as places for community. 

I’ll admit that this is a very lofty assertion. But it is a worthwhile one, and it’s not as though we’re starting from scratch. In the GLAM sector, several institutions have already begun to embrace a more accessible, experiential, and participatory approach to their work. 

Through the Rijksstudio, the Rijksmuseum has allowed for much of their collection to be viewed by the public. Source.

Perhaps the most well-known and widespread trend in the GLAM sector is growing access to the full collection of an institution through digitization. These collections are available in their entirety, rather than as curated exhibits. The Rijksstudio, a project from the Rijksmuseum, takes this a step further. By allowing visitors to create their own “studio,” or collection of artworks and objects, the Rijksstudio makes apparent the stories that each and every visitor uncovers within the collection. Flowers, fancy headgear, animals and more – studios created by users reveals the multitude of stories hidden within the collection that are yet to be told. 

With less than 5% of the collection shown in the museum, the SFMOMA decided that the best way to show off their artwork was to bring it out from the museum. Source.

In the same vein, GLAM institutions are changing how they display their collections physically. For museums like the San Francisco Museum of Modern Art, an institution that displays less than 5% of their collection within the actual museum, physical display isn’t enough. In June 2017, SFMOMA launched “Send me SFMOMA,” a digital initiative wherein a person would text a number, with a keyword, colour, or emoji, and the SFMOMA would send them a related artwork by text. The aim was to show more of SFMOMA’s collection with people across the United States, and through this service, people could personalize what artwork they received. The response was overwhelming; by the end of July 2017, SFMOMA had received over 3.7 million text requests. Many, many people invited art and culture into their daily lives, and they didn’t have to visit the museum to do it.  

More than just their collections, GLAM institutions have also begun to digitize exhibits, opening up their content and stories to audiences beyond their buildings. The Warsaw Rising Museum exhibits decades of Polish history online. Source. 

Part of that “listening mode” I mentioned earlier is learning where people are at. For some, that is not within a GLAM institution, for a multitude of reasons. As with moving collections online, many institutions have begun to move visitor experiences beyond their walls as well. SFMOMA did so through a digital service, bringing a personally curated art experience to people across the United States. The Warsaw Rising Museum  delivered an entire exhibit through a website. “Warsaw Rising” depicts the history of Warsaw from 1918 onward. The focus is, of course, is the Warsaw Rising, but there is certainly a thematic emphasis on Warsaw as a dynamic, developing city, despite its hardships. It is a fully interactive exhibit with compelling text, audio, and visuals – it is indeed an entire exhibit online. 

Europeana provides access for 50 million digitized items from many European institutions. Source.

I want to close by returning to Douglas McCarthy for a moment. As Collections Manager for Europeana Collections, McCarthy is part of an organization that works with thousands of European archives, libraries, and museums to share cultural heritage with the aim of making it easier to use, whether that be for work, learning, or fun. This approach is useful, I think, for the GLAM sector wholesale; in working to make cultural heritage easier to use, access, and explore, we make it accessible to a wider public, thereby opening up our institutions to a greater world of possibility. 


8 November 2018

THE 2018 OMA CONFERENCE IN GLAM ANALOGIES



The 2018 Ontario Museum Association Conference had the theme "Collaborating for Impact: Not Business as Usual," and I ventured in prepared to capture as much GLAM collaboration as possible.

I'm not sure whether it was unique to OMA, or common across all conferences, but people sure liked their analogies--with so much great discussion, these three GLAM-related analogies (GLAMalogies?) seemed the best way to organize this post.


Analogy 1: Silos. Source.

Analogy 1: Escaping our GLAM Silos


This first analogy is not new, and describes GLAMs' tendencies to operate only within their own spheres.

In the panel Collapsing Silos, Building Communities: Glam Sector Collaborations, Michael Rikley-Lancaster of the Mississippi Valley Textile Museum, Lisa Snider of the Archives Association of Ontario, and Kerry Badgley of the Ontario Library Association discussed current collaborations between GLAMs, and how fruitful such collaborations can be.

Michael Rikley-Lancaster described how one collaboration can create long-lasting synergy. The Almonte Branch of the Mississippi Mills Public Library had digitized their town's newspaper, but had not done anything with it. In 2012, the library partnered with the Mississippi Valley Textile Museum, who helped give the newspaper an online platform and bring it to public eyes. Rikley-Lancaster noted that the digitized newspaper platform still gets at least 10000 hits a month.

This one collaboration led to future projects: when the library was tight for space, they moved their collection of textile books right into the textile museum, creating more traffic at the museum through visitors coming to use that collection.

Breaking down the silos between our institutions can lead to benefits for both the institutions and their communities, and can create to long-lasting relationships.

Analogy 2: Cats. Source.

Analogy 2: Archives are like Cats


In this same session, Lisa Snider compared archives to cats: on the one hand, as access institutions, archives want people to come visit, but on the other hand, as preservation-focused institutions, they want to keep people at a distance.

Here is another way that GLAM partnerships can be fruitful. While both archives and museums focus on preserving primary, one-of-a-kind materials, archives, unlike museums, often lack the infrastructure for exhibiting and engaging audiences with that material. Collaborations between Archives and GLMs can help make archives visible, bringing their collections to public eyes through institutions that have ample infrastructure in place for such attention.

As Lisa Snider put it, archives can piggyback on what libraries and museums are doing to provide lifelong learning experiences. GLAMs can work together to balance that cat-like temperamental push and pull of preservation versus access.

(I love this analogy. What kind of cat would your favourite archive be?)

Analogy 3: Perfume. Source.

Analogy 3: GLAMs should Market Themselves like Perfume


This analogy comes from keynote speaker Stephen Abram, Executive Director of the Federation of Ontario Public Libraries. Abram pointed out that we do not market Chanel no. 5 by saying it is a smelly yellow liquid--it is the perfume's evocative smell that sets it apart, which advertisers devise clever ways to market to consumers.

Likewise, it is also foolish to market a library by advertising that it has books, to market galleries by advertising that they have art, and to market a museum by advertising that it has exhibits. Abram says that GLAMs have to ask, what is our smell? What do we do on an emotional level?

There was so much other great GLAM discussion that I couldn't fit in this post. During the Plenary GLAM Panel, Shelley Falconer of the Art Gallery of Hamilton, Vickery Bowles of Toronto Public Library, John Roberts of the Archives of Ontario, and Christina Tessier of Ingenium discussed challenges shared across institutions.

I will conclude with some of the excellent, thought-provoking questions they raised:

GLAMs all have a platform to bring topics to public awareness. Do they have a responsibility to harness that space to respond rapidly to current events?


GLAMs all carry a shared privilege of public trust, but what do they do to deserve that trust?


How can GLAMs work together to tackle these questions collaboratively, and arrive at more powerful answers?


Check out #OMAconf2018 for more from the conference!