Showing posts with label restoration. Show all posts
Showing posts with label restoration. Show all posts

8 April 2019

HOW FAR IS TOO FAR?

Conservation Tips & Tricks | Selin Kahramanoglu


Let's talk about ethics.

Picture this: You're a conservator in a prestigious museum (congrats!), and you are tasked with restoring the painting, Woman with a Parasol, by Claude Monet. In this scenario, the painting has been cut along the top of the canvas during its transportation to the museum's collection storage.

It's only ripped. No big deal. Just patch it up, right?

Yes, the tear is near the frame, but in this imaginary scenario the tear also thinly runs down the canvas, and clearly strikes through the image of the young woman in the painting. There's no way to hide the damage. Suddenly, the slashed painting is more problematic than we initially thought. You sure that you want to keep going?

Woman with a Parasol, painted by Claude Monet. Source.
Door Number One: If you choose not to restore the painting, the rip would likely get bigger over time, and it could never be displayed in such a state. Shame would cast a shadow over your institution (sorry, I'm excited for Game of Thrones), because the Monet painting was damaged while in your care. Too bad. There goes your reputation. 

Door Number Two: If you choose to restore the painting, you will need to repair the canvas in the back, but also paint over the front image to cover the ripped edges. The question is, are you willing to paint over an original Monet? If the answer is yes, then welcome to the dark side of conservation practices.


The restoration of art is a task frequently given to conservators. Sometimes objects get accidentally damaged when moving between spaces, and other times it is an action that was purposefully done. Still, how much work can reasonably be done to repair a work of art, or an artifact, before the restoration impedes the integrity of the original work? At what point would a conservator become a contributing artist?

Now, I know these ethical decisions are hard to make, but don't worry. Remember our golden rule: The point of conservation is to protect the current state of the object, using techniques that are reversible in the future.


Ethically, conservators are restricted to doing only what is necessary to conserve the object. That's why we would have to repair the painting's canvas. However, adding more paint to the artwork, on top of Monet's existing work, is another moral dilemma.

Here's the good news: Paint can be removed. Impressionism art has layers upon layers of paint, which can be taken off, even if the paint has been dry for decades. If a conservator chooses to paint on top of Monet's work in order to cover the rip, then yes, the conservator's paint job is reversible. So far, so good.

Sorry, there's bad news: The extent of conservation on an object is subjective. Unfortunately, each conservator is not watched by a jury of experts in the lab, telling them when they've overdone it. How can we trust that a conservator knows when to stop tinkering, repairing, altering?


Don't forget, you are the conservator in this scenario. No one else. The decision is yours to make. The mistakes are also yours to make. Here are four important tips to following best practices when it comes to ethical dilemmas in conservation:
  1. Consult another conservator or specialized expert. Try to not to pick a friend, or a colleague in the same institution, when consulting for a second opinion. You wouldn't want any biased remarks in this case. You need brutal truths on how to proceed with the job.
  2. Research previously completed conservation treatments. There are many examples of a job gone wrong, and it is equally helpful to see what decisions you shouldn't be making. At the same time, a similar situation would show you the processes that someone else has already tested out before you.
  3. Trust your instincts. If you think that you're in danger of going too far, then the answer is probably yes. Do you think your hand is too shaky to patch up the painting today? Then, take a break. Are you unsure as to which solvent test to do? Ask someone. Don't guess, and don't push yourself to do the job.
  4. Take some risks. I know ethical dilemmas are scary, especially if you're the one in charge. Still, we should be trying to push the boundaries of our professions. Demand an answer to tough questions. If you have a strong rationale behind your decision, then do it!

Like most ethical issues, this topic can be debated, and I won't pretend to have a definite solution. However, I encourage you to think about these problems when you go on a museum visit, or tour a historical site this summer. Take a walk through the unknown and dangerous side of conservation!

13 March 2019

MORE THAN JUST BROKEN ARTIFACTS

Conservation Tips & Tricks | Selin Kahramanoglu


Imagine if the wings of Winged Victory were smashed into so many little pieces that it was impossible to recover. It is true that the statue’s head and arm are already missing, but the artwork is made famous by its wings. Currently housed at the Louvre, and dated to almost the 2nd century BCE, this statue demonstrates the essence of Hellenistic marble and artistry. The wings are the iconic part of the statue. They are at the very core of the statue’s significance. The wings are everything.

For conservators, this is a critical moment.

Do they make plaster replicas of the wings, and add it back to the statue so that it is whole again?
Or, do they leave it the way it is?

Statue of Winged Victory, also called Nike of Samothrace. Source.
When it comes to restoration, some of our conservation decisions will be questionable. People will agree with us, and people will certainly disagree too. Still, these tough decisions need to be made. Who is to stay which choice is right? In this post, we think about the general advantages and disadvantages to the restoration of artifacts, and how they are more than just broken objects. 


Advantages

There are a lot of reasons why we might choose to restore a damaged artifact. Especially if it is within the museum’s budget, expertise, and resources to do so, why wouldn’t we try to rescue it? The whole point of conservation is to try to keep the original state of the artifact as much as possible, so of course, conservators would try their best to accomplish that. 

To add, if an artifact is damaged while under the protection of the museum, the institution may wish to erase any evidence of the incident. A museum’s reputation is at risk when pursuing future acquisitions, if the museum has a history of not keeping good care of its artifacts. 

Generally, restoration helps…
  • visitors envision the historical, original state of the artifact on display 
  • forget that the artifact was ever damaged
  • show that the museum has sufficient and up-to-date resources to assist conservation efforts
  • demonstrate the knowledge and skill of the conservator 


Disadvantages

Here's where things get fuzzy. Choosing not to restore an artifact can be considered brave, forward-thinking, or more often, risky. If a museum decides to keep a damaged artifact on display, this might show visitors that the incident is now a part of the object's biography. Conservators might say that the damage has been done, and we need to acknowledge this history, not erase it.

Many people might disagree with this tactic, because the sight of the damage could overwhelm the entirety of the artifact. Perhaps, the broken outline is all you see, and any hope at restoring the whole artifact fades. Sometimes, visitors might be angered when seeing the damaged artifact on display, because it reminds us of the damage that had been unwillingly inflicted. However, should we try to subdue this anger? Couldn't this frustration add more significance to the artifact?

Briefly, the lack of restoration means...
  • acknowledging the incident that caused the damage
  • accepting that the original state of the artifact is now unattainable
  • possibly insinuating that the museum does not have the conservation resources to restore it
  • allowing visitors to think critically about not restoring every artifact


Whether we choose to save a damaged artifact, or not, the decision is difficult and with some consequences. The next time you visit a gallery with a damaged artifact on display, or an object that has had obvious repairs made, let's consider why a conservator might choose to present the object in that way. Maybe, there's more to the story?

See you next month for the next post!


29 November 2018

DEBATING THE AUTHENTICITY OF RESTORATION

Conservation Tips & Tricks | Selin Kahramanoglu

Welcome to the second article of my three-part series about different conservation methods! This week, I will discuss restoration practices, and use a recently reworked famous Italian painting as our case study. Cominciano!

The Last Supper, by Leonardo da Vinci, found at Santa Maria delle Grazie in Milan. Source.
What's the story?

According to a report by The Independent in 2012, The Last Supper was restored out of Leonardo da Vinci's modern studio, by Pinin Brambilla Barcilon and Pietro Marani. The painting had particular damage from grime and also suffered from bad restoration techniques in the past. In 1999, the artwork was finally revealed after twenty years of conservation efforts, but not everyone was pleased.

In situ, the 1498 painting is located on the wall of the Santa Maria delle Grazie in Milan. In true Leonardo da Vinci fashion, the tempera painting is on top of sealed stone, which is prone to discolouration and deterioration, especially when exposed to humid climates overtime. However, some people think that the recent restoration overwhelms the painting, and the original work is barely present. People start asking the question: Is it even a Leonardo da Vinci anymore?

Why bother with restoration?

As mentioned in my previous article of this series, humidity is a major threat to historical artifacts and sites! In this case, there were only two options: 1) The conservators intervene and restore the painting, or 2) The painting continues to deteriorate naturally. What do we do when it comes to an original Leonardo da Vinci masterpiece? Most conservators will choose to rescue it.

The choice to restore a piece of history is not an easy one. For The Last Supper, there isn't much to think about, because the painting was produced from a famous artist. It is culturally valuable, and thus deserves conservation efforts. Yet, other artifacts are not so smussato - for example, some pieces may be ancient and historically interesting, but not too publicized, and often overlooked by the general public. Both scholars and the average person needs to be able to find the object culturally important, so that the artifact is worth the money, labour, and resources for conservation.

Focus on the good!

Apart from saving an artifact from completely disappearing off the face of the earth, restoration is useful for two related reasons: First, a restored piece gives the impression that it is one "whole." From the outside, a good restoration job means that you can't tell between the original and the recent reworkings. The artifact gives the illusion that it has not been slowly deteriorating, but instead seems visually complete and untouched. Molto bene!

Second, a restored artifact (especially a Leonardo da Vinci work) attracts tourists. It is the same idea when something new and sparkly comes on display at a jewelry store. When a historical objects comes out of storage for the first time in years, the public wants to see it - in its entirety. Speaking from experience, visitors don't typically enjoy seeing a tiny fragment of an object, while the rest of the item is lost, or fading to dust.

We can't ignore the bad...

Restoration involves intervention. In my opinion, the moment you alter an artifact, it is no longer 100% original. The Last Supper, for example, is still an authentic work, but the object's identity now has an added layer. Despite efforts to replicate the item as smooth and exact as possible, the object's biography changes, and we add a chapter of restoration to its history. 

Not only this, restoration resources are expensive, difficult to acquire, and need advanced expertise - not the easiest to come by! Mi dispiace, but you need a large amount of funding and support to get a restoration project approved and completed. Moreover, in the past, a bad restoration job is often met with a fierce public outcry and have not always been fixable.


I'll leave the decision up to you! Which do you prefer, restoration or natural deterioration? It's a bit of a debate among conservators, but one thing is for sure - as long as the conservation technique is reversible without causing damage, why not give it a try? Arrivederci amici!

Additional References



1 October 2018

FROM THE ASHES: THE AFTERMATH OF THE FIRE THAT DESTROYED BRAZIL’S NATIONAL MUSEUM

Muse News | Amy Intrator 


Yesterday marked four weeks since the devastating fire that consumed Brazil’s 200-year old National Museum. The past month has been filled with accounts of the museum’s losses and speculation about the systematic problems that led to the fire. The fire has been described as a “global tragedy” but now it’s time to consider how a “global recovery” can take shape.

Photograph capturing the fire at the National Museum of Brazil. Source.


What happened?

On September 2, 2018 an enormous fire broke out at Brazil’s National Museum in Rio de Janeiro. Officials estimated that the fire destroyed 90% of the museum’s collection of 20 million artifacts. There has been an outpouring of anger and disappointment across the world in the wake of the fire. Although the exact cause of the fire is unknown, many blame the government of Brazil for neglecting the country’s cultural institutions and letting the museum fall into disrepair. Brazil’s National Development Bank was in the process of disbursing a loan to the museum, but the funds to provide an “adequate fire safety system” came too late to save the museum.

Photograph of the exterior of the National Museum of Brazil before the fire. Source.


What was lost?

The museum’s staff are still trying to account for the losses in the collection, but the outlook is bleak for the majority of the artifacts. The museum had diverse collections including artifacts from Brazil’s Indigenous cultures, an Ancient Egypt collection, and artifacts related to anthropology and archaeology – including 11,500 year-old “Luzia,” the oldest human fossil discovered in the Americas. Many members of Brazil’s Indigenous communities have expressed the tragic loss of the museum’s Indigenous collection. The Indigenous collection included audio recordings of Indigenous leaders who have since died, and writings of languages that are now extinct. The collection represented a tangible connection to history, which has now been irrevocably severed.

Photograph of the National Museum of Brazil's display of "Luzia," an 11,500 year-old skull that was used to create a digital reconstruction of her face. Luzia was lost in the fire. Source. 


Where does recovery begin?
It is difficult to imagine a way to “rebuild” a museum that has lost such a significant piece of their collection, but there are several efforts to assist the museum. The physical rebuilding of the museum will be extremely costly, and Brazil’s government is in the process of seeking local and international assistance to fund the project. Funding the physical rebuild is one problem, but questions remain: How do you begin “recovering” a collection with few remaining traces? How can the global community support the National Museum?

“The [University of Toronto Museum Studies program] has sent a letter of support and an offer of assistance to the National Museum in Brazil,” states Dr. Cara Krmpotich, the Director of the University of Toronto Museum Studies Program. “We are approaching the situation from both top down, and bottom up, offering assistance based on needs identified by museum and scholarly colleagues in Brazil.” According to Krmpotich, assistance may come in the form of digital transcription here in Toronto, or skilled labour on the ground in Rio. The faculty will take their lead from the staff of the museum, who are likely in the process of mobilizing a strategy in the wake of the fire.

In addition to financial and scholarly efforts to help the museum, there have been several initiatives to digitally “reconstruct” the collection. Wikipedia recently launched a crowd-sourcing initiative to encourage the global community to upload photos to Wikimedia of any artifacts from the National Museum collection.



Similar digital recovery projects have sprung up across the internet, but is this the answer to large-scale restoration? Krmpotich, and many other museum professionals, would prefer to hear what the museum wants “on their terms” rather than follow the lead of a 3rd party platform. Another notable project is underway at the Federal University of Rio de Janeiro. The students of the University’s Museum Studies program are gathering images, videos, documents, and drawings of exhibits and artifacts in order to create a digital archive. The Federal University was in charge of the museum’s operations and collections, so the students are extremely close to situation.

The restoration of the National Museum is the priority in the wake of this tragedy, but the fire begs the question of how we can implement policies to protect the structural integrity of museums across the world. We may assume that the fire in Brazil couldn't happen here in Canada, but as Krmpotich states, “we shouldn’t be so hasty to assume this is a problem in other places.”

21 May 2018

MAX STERN: DEVELOPMENTS IN A RESTITUTION STORY 70 YEARS IN THE MAKING

MUSE NEWS

BY: AMY INTRATOR

Over the past couple weeks, you may have seen the name Max Stern frequenting news headlines. On May 3rd, 2018, news broke that two Canadian curators have withdrawn from a high-profile exhibit about Max Stern. A few days later, on May 7th, a ceremony took place in Munich to restitute a painting to the Max and Iris Stern Foundation.

In today’s edition of #MuseNews, I’ll be diving into the backstory of Max Stern and the long-fought battle for the restitution of Nazi-confiscated artwork.

Image of a young Max Stern in Germany. Source.

Who was Max Stern?

Max Stern was born in München-Gladbach, Germany, in 1904. After earning a doctorate in art history, Max Stern took over management of Galerie Julius Stern, his father’s art gallery in Düsseldorf, Germany. Max Stern inherited the gallery after his father’s death in 1934, but he soon faced the restrictive laws of Nazi Germany, which essentially made it impossible for him to operate his gallery as a Jewish citizen. After facing increased pressure from the Reich Chamber of Fine Arts, Stern liquidated the gallery’s inventory. Stern moved to England, and a few years later to Canada, where he later owned the Dominion Gallery in Montreal. Stern had an extremely successful career as an art dealer in Canada, where he remained until his death in 1987. For a more detailed biographical sketch, read the National Gallery of Canada's description of the Max Stern Fonds.

What is the Max Stern Art Restitution Project?

After Stern’s death, McGill, Concordia, and the Hebrew University of Jerusalem became the primary beneficiaries of Stern’s estate. In his lifetime, Max Stern did not openly discuss his life in Germany, so it was only after his death that researchers handling his estate discovered his connection to Galerie Julius Stern. Records also revealed that Max Stern had filed a restitution claim in 1948, which listed 20 paintings and prints that were a part of his lost art collection. In light of this discovery, the beneficiaries of Stern’s estate established the Max Stern Art Restitution Project to recover over 400 paintings that had been unethically taken from Max Stern and now belong to museums and art collectors worldwide. The Project has successfully recovered several works and continues an ongoing pursuit to recover the entire lost collection.

The painting Girl from the Sabine Mountains (circa 1840) was restituted by the Max Stern Art Restitution Project in 2008. Source.

What’s the story behind the upcoming exhibit Max Stern: From Dusseldorf to Montreal?

One of the artworks recovered by the Max Stern Art Restitution Project is the self-portrait of the painter Wilhelm von Schadow. On April 7th, 2014, the Stadtmuseum Düsseldorf returned the artwork, which had once belonged to Max Stern. The return of the painting marked a victory for the restitution project, but it also spurred a partnership between the city of Düsseldorf and the Max Stern Art Restitution Project. The city announced that a major exhibition on Max Stern’s life and legacy would launch in 2018 in Düsseldorf, where it would then tour to Haifa, Israel, and then Montreal.

Exterior of the Stadtmuseum Dusseldorf. Source.

On November 15th, 2017, after the exhibition had been in the works for over three years, the city of Düsseldorf announced the exhibition was cancelled. The reason provided for the abrupt cancellation was “current demands for information and restitution in German museums in connection with the Galerie Max Stern.”

Following the cancellation there was immediate outcry. Many commentators suggested the city was still fearful of returning artworks in their ownership, such as Wilhem von Schadow’s painting The Artist’s Children (1830), which previously hung in the mayor’s office and is now the subject of a restitution claim. Amidst the outcry, an announcement on December 21st, 2017: the city of Düsseldorf reversed the decision to cancel the exhibition.

Why is the restitution of Nazi-confiscated art still problematic today?

The saga of the Max Stern exhibit indicates that just as restitution was difficult in 1948, when Max Stern first sought the return of his artworks, it is still a challenge today. In theory, the restitution of Nazi-confiscated art is encouraged and adopted as best practice within museums, but the actual recovery of lost art becomes problematic when individuals and institutions with vested interest in the artworks are involved.

The fraught exhibition only emphasizes the importance of the Max Stern Art Restitution Project, as we are in need of organizations that fight for restorative justice to set the precedent for future restitution claims.