Showing posts with label Local History. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Local History. Show all posts

30 October 2020

THERE'S SOMETHING STRANGE IN YOUR NEIGHBOURHOOD: HAUNTED WALKS, DARK TOURISM & LOCAL HERITAGE

 Heritage Moments | Madison Carmichael 


In 2014, Victoria, B.C. proudly branded itself as British Columbia’s “most haunted city.” At a cursory glance, this seems a strange way to promote tourism; but in 2014, being spooky was all the rage, as evidenced by Tristin Hopper’s article for the National Post, wherein he declared that a haunting could make the difference between profit and bankruptcy. According to John Adams, founder of Victoria’s Ghostly Walks, the public’s taste for the paranormal saw a marked increase in 2014. Not only were places willing to admit that they were haunted; they promoted it. Ghost walk tours are now offered in virtually every Canadian city.

These walking tours are wildly popular. The Haunted Walk, a tour agency operated out of Ottawa, Kingston, and Toronto, has hosted over 400,000 guests on such tours (including yours truly!) over the past 25 years. Put “ghost walk” into Google, and you’ll be bombarded with results announcing an astronomical number of such tours all across the country, regardless of locale. 

The allure of ghost tourism has, of course, found its way to heritage work. As a result, chilling walking experiences such as those offered by The Haunted Walk bolster local heritage work through the addition of ghost stories, paranormal intrigue, and even the outright macabre to the local, historical repertoire, attracting visitors and raising much needed revenue that supports heritage work.

Guide for A Haunted Walk in Ottawa Jail. You see the spook? (Source)

Beatriz Rodriguez Garcia describes ghost tourism as the visitation of places associated with ghosts, such as cemeteries, haunted houses, castles, and historic towns. Ghost tours are structured very similarly to your run-of-the-mill tour, but they are done so in direct contrast to such tours, offering participants an alternative experience —namely, a spooky one. 

While these tours vary immensely based on location, they all have a similar structure: lantern-wielding guides lead participants along a route through a city or site, stopping along the way to tell ghostly or else esoteric stories at important landmarks. Most tours occur around evening time, as the encroaching darkness adds a certain je-ne-sais-quoi to the spooky stories. These tour routes depend on the stories they tell — some lean on existing ghost stories, but many organizations will do additional, archival research — as the tours map either directly onto the places where the events took place or nearby.

Edinburgh is colloquially considered one of the world's most haunted cities, and it certainly has a dark history to back that up. (Source)

Ghost tourism is oft regarded as a lighter form of dark tourism, which is most simply defined as tourism associated with sites of death, disaster, or difficult heritage. Dark tourism is a recent entry to the heritage industry and a highly contested one at that. Ghost tourism sits rather awkwardly in dark tourism literature, as most scholars consider it a frivolous and superficial form of entertainment. The “frivolity,” as it were, derives from the fact that ghost tours focus mostly on the paranormal, and they tend to mix entertainment, fun, and education in with the spooks. On the whole, ghost tours are an emerging, geographically dynamic form of dark tourism. 

But as with most aspects of dark tourism, there is an ethical dimension to consider. In her study of ghost tours in Edinburgh and Toledo, respectively, established and emergent destinations for ghost tourism, Rodriguez Garcia surmised that both tour companies considered their tours in the same light as any other tourist activity: an indirect means to preserve local history and, since their sites were privy to greater atrocities and more macabre stories, a means to promote awareness that would prevent such events from occurring again. The ethical issue arises from charging ticket prices for the telling of “horrible and macabre stories” in these cities, as their tours were largely related to tales of human. However, she does admit that ghost tours are mainly entertaining and perhaps a dash educational, and so as with any other service commodity, there is a fee.

This particular haunted, historic inn caught my eye on my Haunted Walk. Every time I walked past this inn after I took that tour, I thought about the ghost. (Courtesy of Madison Carmichael)

Last summer, on a lark, I went on a Haunted Walk. This was deeply uncharacteristic of me, as my threshold for ghost stories has always been very, very low. But I was a tour guide in Kingston, Ontario, at the time, so while I knew a great deal of the local history already, I was intrigued by the idea of rereading streets I’d walked for five years previously in the context of ghosts. 

This is the strength of ghost tours; they are just as enticing to locals as they are to tourists. Locals map their daily lives onto particular routes and specific landmarks. In contrast to tourists, they have an intensely personal sense of geography of a given space. My haunted walk cast all the gorgeous little historic inns near my neighbourhood in Kingston, many of which I walked by to get coffee or go to work, in a truly creepy light. 

It’s been argued that the benefits of bringing paranormal tourism to historic sites are many. Local ghost tour groups interpret historic sites as well as their ghosts, and in the process, they teach visitors about their historical significance. The intermingling of the haunted and the historical allows for ghostly reinterpretation of the site and renewed interest in its history for demographics new and old, bolstering local heritage in the process. 

The Haunted Walk proclaims that “You’ll never look at the city the same way again!” They certainly refer to the inherent spook of the tours, but ghost tours do add new context to the ordinary. And whether you believe in ghosts or not, there’s always a bit of history mixed in there to make up the difference. 

27 May 2020

NOTHING FISHY TO SEE HERE: "FROM TIDES TO TINS" AT THE GULF OF GEORGIA CANNERY NATIONAL HISTORIC SITE

Exhibition Reviews | Madison Carmichael


Due to the global pandemic crisis, museums and galleries the world over were forced to close back in March, and months later, they remain closed. So, as you might imagine, Exhibition Reviews will look a little different this summer. Museums and galleries in recent months have moved quickly to redirect their visitors towards digital offerings, which presents us with the unique opportunity to explore such offerings and delve into the world of digital and online exhibitions. 

Given that I cannot physically go to a museum exhibition at present, I decided to cast a wide net (pun intended) and find something far from home and foreign to me; and so I landed upon “From Tides to Tins: Salmon Canning in BC,” an online exhibition about the history of Canada’s west coast salmon canning industry from 1870 to 2017. 

“From Tides to Tins” was produced in collaboration by the Gulf of Georgia Cannery, which is a historical site, and the Virtual Museum. The latter is currently run under the auspices of the Canadian Museum of History as a funding program to help institutions mount their own online exhibitions, which they then host on virtualmuseum.ca.

This page could function much like an introductory panel. It lays out what the exhibition will consist of. (Source)
Most exhibitions work very hard to immerse you. They employ evocative visuals, purposed lighting, and looping soundscapes. With an online exhibition, housed solely on personal technology and more critically within your home, it is very much up to you to create the atmosphere. Times being what they are, my current residence is filled with the myriad cacophony of my family and dog, to say nothing of the dishwasher, washing machine, and dryer running in the background, and so interruptions are a constant. As such, I headed over to YouTube to see what I could find in terms of soundscapes (here are a few). They tended toward the fantastical, but the sound of water, with seagulls echoing behind it, did the job well enough. 

“From Tides to Tins” consists of four overarching sections: Timeline, Working the Line, Map, and Game. The timeline takes you through more than a hundred years of the west coast fishing industry: from time immemorial to our very recent past, divided into distinct periodical segments. It is enormously comprehensive, covering early trade agreements between Indigenous people such as the Stó:lo and fur traders, mechanization, immigration, and the labour movement.

The timeline portion of the exhibition. Interestingly, you can either follow it temporally or by theme (i.e., global events, social change, environment) - a good use of its digital format. (Source)
In telling the history of this region and trade in this fashion, “From Tides to Tins” acknowledges, early and explicitly, the ethnic diversity of the labourers within the fishing industry, and it does not shy away from the racism inherent to policies of the time (i.e., the Head Tax) and how they influenced and were influenced by whichever industry required labourers at any given time. In doing so, the timeline endeavors to tell a more complete and comprehensive history of this region and those who laboured within it. This is also shown in the photos used to demonstrate the various steps of “Working the Line:” the various archival sources are representative of the Chinese, Japanese, Indigenous, and European men and women who worked either on fishing boats or in canneries all along the Canadian west coast. 

The timeline also notes the rise of over-fishing and accompanying regulations such as the Wilmot Commissions (1890 & 1892) and the Pacific Salmon Treaty (1930/37), which brings ecology into the conversation and invites the visitor to consider how this successful industry may have affected local salmon populations over time. 

From the portion of "Working the Line" entitled "Cleaning." The caption below the photo reads: "Indigenous women wash fish during canning preparation at a BC cannery. The photo is courtesy of the Delta Museum and Archives. (Source)
“Working the Line” and the “Map” portions of the exhibition paint a comprehensive picture of just how numerous and widespread canneries were along the western coast of British Columbia as well as what work within one would have entailed. The exhibition breaks this down into a fourteen-step process, from unloading fish from boats to packing and shipping. Each step details precisely how it would have been done and is accompanied by a short video from an industrial film depicting commercial salmon fishing and canning released in 1948. 

The “Map” is interactive. A sliding scale allows you to move temporally from 1870 to 2018, thereby watching canneries on the west coast diminish in number as time goes on. You are able to click on each one to get a little bit of detail about the cannery in question.

The map in question! Each red dot is a cannery, which you can click on to learn more about it. (Source)
As you might imagine, the fishing industry of the west coast is fairly far – both physically and figuratively – from my Ontarian suburbanite upbringing, so I found that I learned a lot. The great strength of it being an online exhibition was that I was able to experience local history without being local to it. While it may be felt at present that the in-person experience of museum-going cannot be replicated by the digital, the digital does allow you to go farther than you might be able to ordinarily. 

That being said, the reality of online exhibitions is that you’ll do a lot of reading. Which is not to say that that isn’t what you do in a live exhibition, but it’s usually accompanied the act of walking between panels, by immersive soundscapes, and by videos or hands-on activities. 

That brings me to the final part of this exhibition: “Build Your Own Cannery: A Game,” wherein you are put in charge of a new cannery and told to keep costs down and can as much salmon as humanly possible. 

You can choose your location along the B.C coast, your time period, and the name your cannery. I am now the proud proprietor of "Nothing Fishy Here" Cannery. (Source)

This is what I get for listening to my employees and keeping their hours low when they were upset. (Source)


Thanks, Mr. Anderson.

Check out “From Tides to Tins” here!

12 March 2019

FINDING FOODWAYS, PART II.

Research Column | Casarina Hocevar


In my last post, I introduced my upcoming exhibition project, Storefront Stories, and shared a bit about my research into the historical Jewish foodways of Kensington Market. In today’s post, we shall delve into a small tidbit from the research.

Communal Ovens

Perhaps one of my favourite things I have learned in researching Kensington’s Jewish history is a small anecdote about the use of communal ovens. Throughout the 19th and early 20th century, it was common practice in the shtetlekh - villages - of Eastern Europe to use communal ovens to prepare meals for Sabbath. One of my favourite historians of Jewish foodways, Hasia Diner, writes eloquently about the importance of food and food preparation in Jewish life, especially celebratory meals:

The Jewish calendar moved from holiday to holiday, from Sabbath to the six days of the work week, from one life cycle to another, along a food trajectory … The Sabbath meals, three of them…stood out from the weekly food cycle for their richness and elaborateness. …Memoirs of Jewish life in eastern Europe recalled chicken soup, roasted meat, gefillte fish, tcholent (a mixture of beans, meats, potatoes, other vegetables) cooked long and slow, usually in communal ovens, and cakes and fruits, as the embodiment of Jewish family and communal life. - Hasia Diner, Hungering for America, 155 - 156.

As noted in Diner’s quote, meals like tcholent were cooked in a communal oven. Tcholent, similar to a slow-simmering stew, often was cooked overnight to be ready for the lunch/midday meal during Sabbath.

While searching for photographs and information about family businesses in Kensington Market for the exhibition, our team came across the accession file to the Lottman family who ran a bakery at 172 Baldwin St from the 1920s to '40s (and later at 181 Baldwin St. until 1984). In this file there is a note that reads, “[the bakery] had a brick oven and on Friday nights women would bring their pots to keep the chollent warm for the Sa[b]bath.” This short and sweet note indicates to us continuity in Jewish foodways from Eastern Europe shtetlekh to the little Jewish Market in early Toronto: the community followed a weekly routine of observing Sabbath, and to facilitate this, one of the neighbourhood bakeries shared their oven for communal cooking.

Unfortunately, at this stage of our research, we have little evidence or information about whether other bakeries in the market also participated in this practice or which women (and families) would have visited the Lottman bakery to leave their chollent overnight. Nonetheless, small moments like this help illustrate to us some aspect of the market’s foodways: weekly routines (preparing for the Sabbath meals), types of food (tcholent/chollent), division of labour (communal and gendered) and the geography (Lottman’s as a site of communal food production).

A glimpse into the past

Below are two family images of the Lottman's bakery at 172 Baldwin St. In the first: the three women are identified as Sandy Shabinsky, Katie Lottman Grossman, Ruth Berman, in the second: Bella Tichberg and her cousin Henry. Katie Lottman Grossman was Sam Lottman's daughter, who was one of the founders and owners of the bakery, and Bella Tichberg is one of his granddaughters. Later family photos include interior shots from the Lottman bakery and their more industrial kitchen; unfortunately, though, we have no known existing photographs of the original Lottman oven used for communal cooking.

The Lottman family's bakery is one of the businesses to be featured in Storefront Stories.


Permission to use from the Ontario Jewish Archives: “Lottman family,” Ontario Jewish Archives, North York, ON. Accession number: 2013-11-2.

Permission to use from the Ontario Jewish Archives: “Lottman family,” Ontario Jewish Archives, North York, ON. Accession number: 2013-11-2.