Showing posts with label Museum of Ontario Archaeology. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Museum of Ontario Archaeology. Show all posts

11 July 2017

VIRTUALLY EFFECTIVE: TOP 3 CONCERNS WITH USING VIRTUAL REALITY AS AN INTERPRETIVE VEHICLE

MUSEUM INNOVATIONS

BY: HANNAH MONKMAN

In trying to innovate or even just to stay relevant, museums often look to the latest technology to reach their goals. Personally, I love the idea of using virtual reality (VR) as a vehicle of interpretation in museums (noting that yes, virtual reality and augmented reality are different). I believe VR could be used to effectively immerse the visitor in a new environment and provide another level of engagement in an exhibit. Eager to see this in practice, I recently visited two museums in London, ON that both featured VR options in their exhibits through the use of an Oculus Rift.

Roadtrip!! Source.

The first museum I visited was the Royal Canadian Regiment Museum (RCRM), which included a VR experience that takes you into the Battle at Vimy Ridge. Unfortunately, I couldn't get this experience to work—whether the machine was broken, turned off, or the instructions on how to use it were simply unclear, it was definitely a disappointing moment of the visit. The second museum was the Museum of Ontario Archaeology (MOA), which featured a VR longhouse that visitors can explore.


The virtual reality booth with Oculus Rift headset at the Royal Canadian Regiment Museum. Photo courtesy of Hannah Monkman. 

These experiences emphasized some of the risks involved with using high-tech of any sort in an museum environment, and helped inform my understanding of using tech in museums. Here's a rundown of what I learned:

1. Digital technology generally requires specialized maintenance, and staff must be trained to troubleshoot any issues with the tech (especially if the creation of the tech was contracted to external companies). Whether that means simply turning it off and then on again, or fixing broken components, interactive components of displays should be working as often as possible. I visited the RCRM specifically to see the VR exhibit and was frustrated when it did not work. I felt that it was more disappointing to see the cool tech and then have it not work, than if they had not included the tech at all. If you don't have staff on hand who knows (or can learn) how to care for the outsourced tech, perhaps consider a less complex option.

Sometimes dealing with technology isn't as difficult as it may seem. Source.

2. Consider the ethical implications of your VR experience. The psychological impact and ethics related to virtual reality have not been studied much yet at this point. However, concerns have been voiced about the implications of inhabiting a virtual body along with the realistic levels of immersion VR experiences can offer. While I did not get to try the VR at the Regiment Museum, I do know that the experience takes the user to the front lines of the battle. Especially since the experience was designed specifically for grade school students, I question the ethics of such an experience—not that it will negatively affect all users, of course, but that it has the potential to do so since the explosions and gunshots are allegedly very realistic. The effects could be minimal, or be on opposite sides of the spectrum as the users become either desensitized to violence or traumatized in extreme cases due to their experience. Placing the user in the position of a soldier in a 4D virtual reality experience is very different from learning the content in other formats.

If simply watching a movie can affect how we perceive things like war, how would "living" it through VR affect us? Source.

3. Museums often have a habit of using tech for tech's sake—but this can be an ineffective way to engage your visitors. Before committing large amounts of resources to tech like VR, ask yourself: what is this adding to the exhibit? What am I trying to convey with this, and is it actually effective to use VR to do so? The virtual reality at MOA was interesting experience in VR, but less interesting in terms of the content. Walking through a longhouse and picking up objects within a 5 minute time limit provided no additional information for me, especially when physical longhouses were outside on museum grounds. Despite initially thinking that 5 minutes was not a very long time, I found myself running out of things to do or explore in the experience before it was over. After I finished, I found myself thinking, "Why is this here?" Especially since there was a small additional fee to use the VR here, it is definitely in the museum's best interest to make the visitor think it was worth it—whether they paid a few extra dollars or simply paid with their time.

So, while I stand firmly in the position that VR could be used as an incredibly effective way of interpreting content and engaging the visitor, museums have to be careful that they're not using technology like virtual reality "just because." Rather, it should be used because its unique qualities add something that couldn't be attained by another interpretive vehicle. Instead of chasing after the newest technologies, museums should focus on the interpretive potential and the resulting visitor experience when considering how to make exhibits innovative.

tldr; virtual reality has great innovative potential, but only with careful thought about the risks and benefits of using the technology. As long as you think it through and can justify using the tech, VR could be a great option for your museum.

With thorough consideration, you can definitely "follow your dreams" in innovative pursuits. Source.

8 June 2015

COLLECTIONS WITHOUT CONTEXT: REDISCOVERING "OLD WORLD" COLLECTIONS AT THE MOA

RESEARCH COLUMN

BY: MARY SIMONDS

The fantastic thing about the Museum Studies program is that it opens up a plethora of new research interests and questions that you never considered before. You find yourself wanting to investigate topics that interest you outside of your courses and assignments. Suddenly, just like that! (*finger snap*) You find yourself down the research rabbit hole and you are just too invested to stop. This is exactly what happened to me, and why I have decided to complete a master’s thesis (as scary as this may seem ....).

Source.

I initially had trouble nailing down a coherent research topic for my thesis, but I knew I had a general interest in collections. It was a professor from my undergraduate days at Western that finally came through with an idea for me.  She sent me a link to an online exhibition about two mysterious collections of Roman-Britain pottery and Mesopotamian artifacts discovered in the basement of the Museum of Ontario Archaeology (MOA) in 2011. The only documentation associated with them was a letter and a handful of index cards. It was a complete mystery how the collections from ancient Mesopotamia and Roman-Britain ended up in the basement of a museum dedicated to archaeology in Ontario.

Samian Ware bowl from Roman Britain. Source.

The MOA conducted an investigation and found that the Mesopotamian collection was originally excavated from Ur in 1922 and was then sent to the British Museum. In 1933, it was gifted to Western University’s President, Sherwood Fox, because they were classified as “duplicates”. The Roman-British pottery was excavated from a WWII bomb crater and then sent to MOA’s founder, Wilfrid Jury, in 1950. MOA is an affiliate of Western University and was originally located on Western University’s campus sharing their archives. When the museum relocated to its own location in the 1970s, the collections moved with it. 

Large pottery vessel from Ur. Source.

There was so much that intrigued me about the story behind these collections! The lack of associated documentation, the use of the term “duplicates” by the British Museum, and the surprising mobility of these collections. All of this sparked the questions; how is the relationship between information and objects formed?  As well, how does this relationship determine what kind of role certain objects play within a museum environment? Both the Mesopotamian and Roman-Britain collections were assigned value by various people/institutions; and that decision has affected their current value.  

So much of the inherent value of museum objects comes from the context and information associated with them. Through this they become valuable in either a heritage context or an educational context; especially archaeological collections. In archaeology, context is everything! It could be argued it is more important than the artifacts themselves! This holds true when the artifacts become part of a collection. I intend to use object biography as my lens of study. Object biography advocates that, much like people, objects are transformed through time, space, and meaning. Meaning is acquired in a variety of ways, through functional or physical change, or the events and people connected to the object. I believe that the meaning and function of these collections have been altered many times over the course of their “life” as museum objects; and because of these alterations their value has also been altered. 

That is the basics of my thesis! I have a long way to go towards completing my research and there are many avenues I need to pursue to try and uncover as much as I can about the collections and their journey. I cannot wait to dive even deeper down the rabbit hole! 

Works Cited:
Kopytoff, Igor. 1986. "The Cultural Biography of Things: Commoditization as Process". The Social Life of Things. New York: Cambridge University.
 
Editor’s Note: Mary Simonds is a first year MMSt student with an honours BA in Anthropology from the University of Western Ontario. She is currently completing an internship at the very same museum where she is conducting her thesis research, the Museum of Ontario Archaeology in London, Ontario. She is interning as a Collections/Curatorial assistant and was very excited about the MOA’s “AMAZING collections facility and high-tech archaeology lab” which she “freaked out” over on her first day.