Showing posts with label Interpretation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Interpretation. Show all posts

11 March 2020

WHAT WE NEED IS A STORY: RE-FRAMING INTERPRETATION IN ART GALLERIES

GLAM Guide | Madison Carmichael


Just before the San Francisco Museum of Modern Art’s grand re-opening in 2017, Chief Content Officer Chad Coerver posited that the wall label wasn’t enough for the average visitor. Instead, he argued: 

“...what visitors really need is a story – a memorable way to connect with a fundamentally foreign object.”
In advocating for more appealing and accessible art stories in the SFMOMA, Coerver echoed almost a decade of transformation in art interpretation, wherein museum staff across departments worked to shift the visitor’s conceptualization of art as well as their experience of it. 

From 2002 to 2010, three art galleries in particular in North America engaged in interpretive transformations: the Detroit Institute of Art (DIA), the Art Gallery of Ontario (AGO), and the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston (MFA). These three art institutions also share similar mission statements that can be boiled down to: engage people with art and help them to make meaning from it. 

The Detroit Institute of Art did indeed pilot a new model of interpretation in the early 2000s. (Source)

The DIA undertook a major re-installation project from 2002 to 2007. This endeavor was guided by an interpretive approach that emphasized experiences with art rather than lessons in art history, and the objective was to support visitors’ efforts to engage with art by telling stories and making connections with universal human concerns. In a study conducted at the DIA to evaluate the efficacy of this new interpretive strategy, evaluators found three main ways for visitors to find meaning: discovering something familiar or something to which they could make a personal connection, learning or discovering something new, or (less frequently) expressing a preference for the subject or medium of the artwork. 

On the whole, the evaluators discovered that the most common way visitors found personal meaning in the galleries was to relate first to the visual aspects of the art through their own experience and then to utilize the museum’s provided interpretation to go further with their understanding. As such, it was important for the interpretation to provide relevant, meaningful information about the artworks that would support personal meaning.

The AGO re-displayed the majority of its collections in an effort to position art as political, using them to discuss issues and ideas facing visitors currently. (Source)

The AGO also launched a redevelopment project in 2002, which culminated in their reopening with a newly extended building and fully re-displayed collections in 2008. The transformation at the AGO was oriented around questions posed by Judy Koke, Deputy Director of Education and Public Programming: why is the visitor here, and what do they need out of their visit? 

Interpretation at the AGO located the answer to those questions in personal meaning and connection. At the time, the AGO abandoned the practice of displaying art by historical chronology and instead displayed their collections through issues and ideas. This was a fascinating departure from conventional practice, as it necessitated that the artworks on display needn’t be the most prestigious or most famous but rather those that best illustrated the ideas and issues posed in that particular space. 

This approach served the AGO’s purposes quite neatly, for – much like the DIA – they hoped not only to develop an understanding of art historical chronologies but to inspire personal connections with art. Artworks were designed to function as departure points for exploring the broader story within a gallery space. 

The MFA situated art as socio-objective. As such, they explore how any given artwork functioned or else represents a facet of society or social practices. (Source)

Most recently, the MFA opened the Art of the Americas wing of their institution in 2010. The wing itself was imposing: it comprised of four floors and forty-eight galleries, as well as four “Behind the Scenes” galleries. The brochure detailing this portion of the museum implored visitors to design their own path according to their own interests and needs. Furthermore, visitors were encouraged to make use of the central gallery on each floor, which were designed to provide a broad brushstroke of the level’s theme and contents. 

Barbara T. Martin, Alfond Curator of Education at the MFA, noted that museum staff had begun to realize that the visitor needed a way in. To the notion that objects speak for themselves, unfortunately prevalent in museums, she said: “when you say that the object speaks for itself, usually you’re someone with a PhD who has read a lot of words to get to the point where the object can talk to you.” This is not, as you might imagine, a very easy point to get to, nor a very accessible one! As such, the MFA rather appropriately took a more informal and conversational tone with their interpretation. 

The goal, according to Benjamin Weiss, Head of Interpretation, was not for visitors to read the walls, but for the walls to speak to visitors. The MFA didn't aim to change what they said: it was to re-frame the questions – changing “what is this thing? to “why am I looking at this thing?” It was to ask – and to answer – why we should care. 

The point, Martin stated, was for visitors to feel empowered to engage with the artworks on display by giving them the tools to do so. But more crucially, it was important that visitors know that “there isn’t some mysterious practice that you’re supposed to know if you’re in this kind of place.” 

The SFMOMA similarly re-evaluated the interpretation of their collections between 2013-2017, when they underwent massive physical and programmatic transformations. They too found a need for personal connection in their galleries. (Source)
Much like Coerver, these institutions found a need for stories: stories written and told by the institution but also those brought into the gallery space by visitors. The DIA, the AGO, and the MFA embraced the necessity of re-framing how visitors experienced art, and they did so through museum interpretation that emphasized the relevance of art and the personal connections that visitors can make to any number of artworks. So, the question is: in re-interpreting, re-displaying, and re-framing art, do we make art galleries more appealing and accessible spaces for those of us who may find art to be fundamentally foreign? Maybe, maybe not. But it certainly offers visitors a new way to engage with art on display, and that is not an insignificant thing. 

3 April 2018

VISIONS FOR THE FUTURE: MMSt 2018

MUSEUM INNOVATIONS

BY: HANNAH MONKMAN

Hello and welcome to a special issue of Museum Innovations! As the last installment for the term, I decided to go out into our student community and ask our soon-to-be Museum Studies graduates where they think museums are headed in the future. Asking, "what's next for museums?" I wanted to highlight the fantastic ideas and insights of our grads in all areas of the museum field, from collections management to interpretation, diversity and inclusion strategies, and even museum management.

I'm so excited to see all the passion and ambition coming into the field, and with such drive amongst our graduates, we may... dare I say it? ... change the world. 

Source.
Do you agree with these visions for the future of museums? Let's see what our grads have to say!

Collections Management 

"Collections Managers & Conservationists should be more environmentally aware of their material consumption (plastics, crates, tissue paper, etc.) when protecting, shipping and storing objects. I want to learn how to lead the way in best practices and show our colleagues it is possible to waste less!"
- Jessica Baptista 

"Widespread acceptance of the use of deaccessioning in tailoring our overgrown collections to those that best fit our mandates, allowing us to properly preserve what needs to be preserved for future generations. But, of course, great power comes with great responsibility."
- Emily Welsh 

"Collections that are accessible, not just visibly but physically. Accessibility to fit a variety of communities' needs. There is a tendency to 'hoard' objects but at the same time, we say museum objects are for the public. I think museums will start to move towards using the collection to better fit the needs of the public in different ways."
- Kathleen Vahey 


Interpretation and the Visitor Experience 

"I would love to have more interpretation that immerses the visitor in a given experience to foster empathy. I don't think we need to sideline objects as a thing of the past - let's animate them in new ways and facilitate interaction (digitally, using replicas, etc.) through storytelling. Within this framework, I hope to encounter/create museum content that explores the idea of "place" at the heart of an experience. Can places be artifacts themselves?"
- Serena Ypelaar 

Source.

"I think museums are constantly learning and introducing inclusive practices. This proactive programming is preparing the future of museums to be even more aware of and engaged with different visitors’ needs that have historically been overlooked. Now museums are moving in a direction that acknowledges that there is no “average visitor,” and every person that comes into the museum has different needs - whether they are mental, physical, or emotional."
- Aurora Cacioppo

"Museums need to start to incorporating new technologies to become more inclusive and accessible for a wider demographic. I really think that museums are in a state of change already; it's just up to them if they want to take the blind leap into something new."
- Breanna Stephenson 

"Museums are in a transition in two ways. Firstly, the museum exhibition experience is becoming much more visitor-centric with an emphasis on creating a meaningful and memorable narrative with defined and tangible short- and long-term outcomes. Secondly, and especially in Canada, museums are reorienting themselves to embrace and mobilize the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) and continue to build better relations with our Indigenous communities. While it will be a long process, the results of this mobilization will change the face of museological practice in Canada."
- Bretton Weir

Source.
Diversity and Inclusion

"Where are museums headed? As a graduating class we should be asking, where can we take museums? Things I hope for (and these are just a few) include: Increasing interactivity within exhibits and during general programming. (For example, the sold out immersive Infinity Mirrors exhibit at the AGO). Museums that are more inclusive and work with communities to represent their diverse publics. I have every confidence that my graduating class will be able to lead the way in this respect."
- An Eager MMst Grad

"Becoming more relevant to a wider and diverse audience. I’d like to focus on how this can possibly be achieved through programming that is more accessible and applicable to a wider audience. I believe programming is powerful enough to engage, connect and teach a diversity of people."
- Julia Zungri

"I think - or at least I hope! - that we're going to see more concerted and sustained efforts at incorporating diversity and inclusion into museums at all levels. Community-based stories won't just be featured in exhibitions; communities themselves, as partners and staff members, will shape how collections are managed and how the museum operates. For a specific example, I think that we'll be seeing more women in positions of museum leadership in the coming years!"
- Sadie MacDonald 

"It's hard to tell, but I hope to see changes for the better. One thing I want to see is marginalized people (POC, LGBT+, disabled, ...) who are working in the museum field being represented and listened to more, and given more leadership roles."
- Anonymous 

Management and Operations

"More engagement with environmental concerns across the sector, both in programming/exhibitions and on an institutional level: carbon-neutral operations and climate justice programming especially."
- Jennifer Lee

"I believe that we are seeing a greater movement towards specialization in all sizes and facets of cultural institutions. Whereas previously some museums and heritage sites were able to operate with passionate, untrained staff curating and attending collections, developments in curatorial practice and collections management techniques mean that this tradition is no longer sustainable in the competitive cultural market. Small sites, which had previously rolled collections management and curatorial duties into one hybrid position, are moving to separate the two into individual staff members to better handle the rigors of each role and to offer a more appealing product to cultural consumers. Due to the strain this puts on the limited resources these institutions have, I foresee an increase in zero-hour contract labour, allowing these sites to reap the benefits of informed practice while saving money during off-seasons."
- Dan Rose


A sincere thank you to everyone who contributed!

19 January 2018

TURN: (EXPOSING) WASHINGTON'S SPIES

WALK OF FAME

BY: SERENA YPELAAR
"That show/film is so inaccurate!" – every historian ever, at some point 
I don't mean to make light of historical representation (I could write a book about how the inaccuracies of the 2005 adaptation of Pride & Prejudice incense me), but with the ever-expanding popularity of television and film, historical dramas are on the rise.

More historical dramas? George Washington approves. Source.
Though often highly fictionalized or overly nostalgic, historical television can illustrate untold stories for mainstream consumption. Despite often sacrificing elements of history for the sake of storytelling, historical dramas have potential value as educational material by way of compelling interpretation. We lose some context, but what does critical viewing of period dramas offer us in terms of interpretive insight?

The AMC television show, TURN: Washington's Spies shares the little-known story of the Culper Ring, a network of American spies operating against British colonial rule during the Revolutionary War (1775-1783). Much of the series' third season was filmed at Colonial Williamsburg. The Museum of the American Revolution in Philadelphia has displayed costumes from the television show, and even held an advance screening of the fourth season.

AMC's TURN: Washington's Spies uses interpretive techniques to depict intelligence networks operating during the American Revolution. By taking liberties (pun intended) with historical facts, the series aims to interest audiences and foster a general awareness of the Culper Ring's significance. Source.
Using thematic narrative techniques, TURN changed my understanding of the American Revolution, portraying the following real-life individuals who contributed to the victory of the colonists and their ensuing independence.

Jamie Bell plays Abraham Woodhull,
a reluctant Patriot spy in TURN:
Washington's Spies
. The show makes
Woodhull's biography accessible to the
public and highlights his role in the American
Revolution. Source.
ABRAHAM WOODHULL

Abraham Woodhull was a cabbage farmer in Setauket, Long Island, New York, and the lead member of the Culper Ring. Operating under the alias "Samuel Culper", or "722", Woodhull frequently travelled to Manhattan and passed information to General George Washington through courier Caleb Brewster.

BENJAMIN TALLMADGE

A Yale classmate of Nathan Hale (whom the British hanged as a Patriot spy in 1776), Benjamin Tallmadge ("721") was Woodhull's neighbour in Setauket and a major in the Continental Light Dragoons. Stationed in Connecticut, he became director of intelligence under Washington and assembled the Culper Ring, recruiting Woodhull as its key member in 1778.
The Culper Ring's code book. The
Ring's correspondence with Washington
has survived intact. Source.

CALEB BREWSTER

Another Setauket native serving as a courier for the Continental Army, Caleb Brewster ("725") travelled by whaleboat to collect information from Woodhull – letters using the Culper Ring's numerical code – and ferry them from Setauket to Washington's camp.

ANNA STRONG / "AGENT 355"

Anna Strong was a Patriot spy and member of the Culper Ring. Considered by many to be the unknown "Agent 355" in Woodhull's correspondence, it's also possible that "355" was merely the Ring's code for "a lady". Nevertheless, Strong is thought to have hung petticoats outside to signal to the courier, Brewster, though some historians dispute this.

In TURN, Agent 355 is a former slave named Abigail, who collects British intelligence under the employ of Major John André. In this case, such an interpretation diversifies the Culper Ring, both racially and in terms of social class.

Anna Strong (Heather Lind) forges a letter while Caleb Brewster (Daniel Henshall) and Benjamin Tallmadge (Seth Numrich) look on. As the primary means of relaying information, correspondence is a major storytelling device in the series. Source.
The only surviving portrait of Robert
Townsend. Apart from Tallmadge,
little to no images exist of
the other members of the Ring. Source.
ROBERT TOWNSEND 

The least-known spy in the Ring, Robert Townsend worked under the alias of "Samuel Culper, Jr.", or "723" and was adamant that not even Washington should know his name. A Quaker who ultimately turned his back on pacifism, Townsend passed information directly to Woodhull from his work at a coffeehouse in New York. His name was not discovered until 1930.

JOHN GRAVES SIMCOE 

Venerated in Canada due to his founding of York in 1793 and his instrumental role in the abolition of slavery, John Graves Simcoe is mercilessly vilified in TURN. Given that the series' protagonists are American colonists, Simcoe is a natural choice for an antagonist. Some historical evidence loosely supports this portrayal - Simcoe commanded the Queen's Rangers' massacre of sleeping Americans in 1778. Watching the television series was extremely entertaining knowing the context of his future role as Lieutenant Governor of Upper Canada.

A young John Graves Simcoe (Samuel Roukin) and Black loyalist Akinbode (Aldis Hodge) of the Queen's Rangers. 
Though it has its share of inaccuracies, overt nationalism, and exaggerated violence, TURN offers a closer look at the communities affected by British colonial rule in what would eventually become the United States.

In interpreting the American Revolution from the perspective of ordinary colonists, the series taught me about the secret intelligence networks that influenced the war. It also taught me that while accuracy and context are vital to ensuring ethical interpretation, we don't necessarily have to discount dramatic interpretation. Much like television audiences, museum visitors' engagement will vary, so a rich thematic backdrop and strong storytelling provides a solid foundation on which to build learning.


Further Resources: 

Interactive Map of the American Colonies as seen in TURN

Toronto Star: John Graves Simcoe to take a Turn on AMC show's final season

TURN to a Historian (blog): The Historical Accuracy of TURN

TURN: Washington's Spies by Alexander Rose - Book Excerpt

13 November 2017

A SPOONFUL OF SUGAR: EDIBLE ART HISTORY AT THE PORTLAND ART MUSEUM

A MUSE BOUCHE

BY: JENNIFER LEE

How far do the limits of interpretation stretch? In virtually every museum in the world, we see art, artifacts, and specimens interpreted into text to help the visitor understand and connect to them. Over time, and especially after the advent of digital media, interpretation has expanded; we can now expect multimedia interpretives like audio tours, videos, and apps in addition to the ubiquitous wall label. Most of these strategies are basically linguistic and visual, depending on words, images, and perhaps sounds to aid understanding.

Interpretation designed for visitors with disabilities might be experienced primarily through other senses; for example, reproductions of paintings which visitors can touch to understand the painter’s brushstrokes. These strategies also benefit visitors who can see: the more senses we can use to experience something, the better an understanding we can form.

Feeling Van Gogh, a touchable (and smellable) interpretive display designed for visitors with visual impairments, at the Van Gogh Museum, Amsterdam. Source. 

Our senses of scent and taste, however, are underused in museum interpretation, often for perfectly good reasons. There are conservation issues involved in bringing food into museum spaces, and many visitors cannot or would prefer not to experience strong, evocative smells in the gallery. For the adventurous, though, food-as-interpretation might be the next frontier of museum experience.

Jared Goodman interprets art into ice cream sundaes as the Culinary Artist in Residence at the Portland Art Museum in Portland, Oregon, where he designs and hosts a public programming initiative titled ‘Edible Art History’. The residency grew out of the Morgan Street Theatre, the ‘dessert theatre’ ice cream pop-up he runs out of his home. At Morgan Street Theatre events, guests experience ice cream and storytelling at communal tables; the intention is to foster social connection and conversation. The menus are chosen with intent: a course at Goodman’s Dr. Seuss-themed ice cream social drew attention to foods endangered by climate change like pecans, bananas, and chocolate. His yearly Passover seder re-imagines the symbolic foods of the traditional seder as sundaes.

Goodman carried this format over to the Edible Art History programming at the Portland Art Museum. Previously, themes have included A Taste of American Art, A Taste of the 1970s, and 20th Century Abstraction. For each event, Goodman selects three pieces in the museum’s collection and creates an ice cream sundae based on each one. (The sundae form, he explains, is well-suited for the job because it allows for a combination of flavours and textures). The choice of flavours is based on the pieces’ “aesthetic, history, and social context”. At the event, Goodman and visitors are joined in conversation by a museum curator.
Left: City Perspectives (1932) by Raymond Johnson, Portland Art Museum. Right, Jared Goodman's interpretation, a sundae composed of passion fruit ice cream, salted brownie, olive oil, and raspberry shrub. Source.

The interpretations aren’t straightforward visual recreations of each work into edible form, but are inspired by single notes: an element of the work’s history, or a feeling it evokes, might determine the flavour or texture of a sundae. An ingredient local to the setting of a painting, or popular at the time of its creation, might figure into the recipe. Like label writing, tour planning, or any other kind of interpretation, this interpretive strategy must be selective: which aspects of the piece are most interesting or important? Too much information, and you risk overwhelming the visitor; too little, and they’ll walk away without an understanding of the piece.

It’s difficult to get a full sense of Goodman’s interpretive process from the limited information abut the Edible Art History program online (to my knowledge, there are no reviews available, so many of the ice cream/art pairings remain tantalizingly unavailable), but it seems to be grounded in the same principles as most other interpretation: research, critical thought, and a desire to make art personal to the visitor. In a feature by Oregon Public Broadcasting, he examines Helen Frankenthaler’s painting Spaced-Out Orbit. “So how do you get from this to ice cream? Well, the thing that I’ve been thinking about most is this idea of restraint and this idea of intention,” he explains. 

That’s a complex idea for any interpretation to express, let alone in the medium of cream and sugar. I’m struck by the subject matter of previous Edible Art History events: 1970s art and abstraction could be inaccessible and off-putting to visitors without a grounding in art history, but a three-course ice cream tasting probably makes them more palatable.

Helen Frankenthaler, Spaced Out Orbit (1973). Acrylic on canvas. Portland Art Museum. Source.

It’s easy to imagine this idea – local man makes art into ice cream! – as a gimmick designed purely to attract visitors and media attention, where interpretive practice is sacrificed for feel-good, Instagrammable novelty. I’ve suspended my cynicism in this case (besides, this man has my dream job). Goodman and his surprisingly complex sundaes evoke Tilden’s fifth principle of interpretation: “Interpretation is an art, which combines many arts…” When rigorously and thoughtfully applied, the culinary arts can be as provocative and revelatory as in-person or written interpretation, if not more so.

Perhaps, to paraphrase the famous maxim, writing about making ice cream about art is like dancing about architecture, but I put it to you that an interpretive dance about architecture would be amazing, and I have similarly warm feelings about responsible ice-cream based interpretation.

25 September 2017

OUT OF THE QUESTION: ACTIVE LEARNING AT LAURIER HOUSE

MUSEUM MYSTERIES 

BY: SERENA YPELAAR

Welcome back to Musings, everyone! I hope you all had a relaxing and enjoyable summer. The Musings team is excited to get back to sharing museum-related thoughts with you, our wonderful readers.

As I’ve been out of the province all summer, I headed down to Ottawa this past weekend with fellow Musings contributor Emily Welsh to catch up on what I missed in Ontario, most notably the opening of the Canadian History Hall at the Canadian Museum of History. We also visited a hidden gem (and one of my favourite sites in the city): Laurier House National Historic Site.

This Second Empire mansion is situated in close proximity to my alma mater, uOttawa. It's been about three years since I last visited the house, though, so I was looking forward to returning to the home of two prominent Prime Ministers of Canada.
 
Photo courtesy of Serena Ypelaar.
Laurier House is special to me because it's a site where a number of my interests intersect – I love history, Canadian politics, and biography. Sir Wilfrid Laurier lived in the house until his death in 1919. Laurier's wife ZoĂ© later willed Laurier House to William Lyon Mackenzie King, and he moved there in 1923. Upon his death, he left the house and all his belongings to the Canadian Crown, in the absence of any relatives to bequeath it to.
 
Laurier House sits on the corner of Laurier Ave. East and Chapel Street in Ottawa. Photo courtesy of Serena Ypelaar.
While we were there, I realized that wandering through a historic house has a few parallels with detective work. Many rooms in the house are blocked off with barriers – everything in the house is an authentic artifact that belonged to either the Lauriers or King. Since the rooms are staged as they would have been when Laurier or King lived there, there is little space to include detailed interpretive panels other than outside the rooms themselves, or in a pamphlet available at the front door.
 
Part of the drawing room in Laurier House, which contains many objets d'art. Note the reminder not to touch anything - this experience was largely visual. Photo courtesy of Serena Ypelaar.
As a result, most of the knowledge we were gaining was empirical. We used our observational skills to examine Laurier's sitting room chairs or King's extensive library, all without touching anything, of course!

I noticed that most of our thought processes came in the form of questions: I wonder if that was King's or Laurier's? What's that piece of furniture for? Where did King get that tiny scowling bust of Winston Churchill? 

That last question wasn't a joke. There is actually a mean-looking Winston Churchill head in King's upstairs dining room. Photo courtesy of Serena Ypelaar.

The conventions of the historic house challenge our attempts to infer meaning from these artifacts, since the rooms are presented as recreated settings in time. Our "investigations" consist of us looking around a room for clues on how the house's occupants would have used the objects within.

Thankfully, there are interpretive tools in place to ensure that our visits to historic houses aren't just a shot in the dark. In the case of Laurier House, Parks Canada staff were stationed on each floor of the three-story house, ready and willing to answer any of our questions when they arose. 

If I hadn't asked about this bust on the landing, I would never have learned that it's Oliver Cromwell. King was fascinated by him, which shows insight into his political leanings and his values. Photo courtesy of Serena Ypelaar.
I became a bit self-conscious about being an overbearing visitor, merely because I was asking so many questions! My "interrogation" of the staff resembled a self-guided quest for knowledge that was defined specifically by my own curiosity. The content I received was dictated by the types of questions I chose to ask.

Though it's arguably less accessible to have to pursue this information rather than having it all available on the walls, it's also part of the way the house is curated. The interpreters know so much about every piece of furniture, article of clothing, and room; yet it would be overwhelming to have so much content written out (for more on this, stay tuned for my next post about demystifying Canada's history at the Canadian History Hall). For instance, when I was admiring a smart suit in a closet on the second floor, an interpreter caught my interest and told me that Laurier wore it when he was knighted by Queen Victoria.

The suit Laurier wore when he was knighted by the Queen in 1897. Photo courtesy of Serena Ypelaar. 
Without the interpreter, my pseudo-investigation would have drawn a blank. After all, it's not like doing research, where the resources are in front of you in written form; rather, you have access to the artifacts with less written content. The object's placement in the room can serve as a form of context, but speaking with the interpreter allowed me to influence the topical direction of the information that was imparted.

But what happens if we feel too shy to actively pursue the information? Visiting Laurier House put us in the role of detective, but it also forced us to evaluate our own questions and whether they were "worth asking". It can be difficult to get over the social nervousness of asking a lot of questions, but the presence of helpful interpreters is the first step.

Surprisingly, I found that the history of Laurier and King's lives in the house was best delivered in this anecdotal format. The contextual panels in or outside each room of the house provided a good overview of its function and significance, and from there we were able to enrich our understanding through conversations with interpretive staff. Asking them our own questions contributed to the sense that we were standing in the former home of real people. Though they've been discussed countless times in history books, speeches, commemorations, and in public memory, they also had private lives, of which Laurier House offers a glimpse.

Sitting on the doorstep of my favourite house in Ottawa! Photo courtesy of Serena Ypelaar.
Each time I visit Laurier House and step back into the inner lives of these two Prime Ministers, I see not only the legacy of the Liberal Party in the first half of the 20th century, but also the distinct personalities of Sir Wilfrid Laurier and William Lyon Mackenzie King.

Even though it was at times a little bit frustrating to have all these questions and no immediate answer, having to ask my questions to a live interpreter made me feel in command of my own learning, and it offered me access to stories that I might not otherwise have been able to appreciate. Probing into aspects of Laurier's and King's lives so many years after their deaths has enabled me (and hopefully many other visitors) to connect with them on a personal level, and to unravel the biographical mysteries of two very different leaders of our country.

Have you ever gone investigating at a historic site to find information that's not in plain view? What did you learn? 

11 July 2017

VIRTUALLY EFFECTIVE: TOP 3 CONCERNS WITH USING VIRTUAL REALITY AS AN INTERPRETIVE VEHICLE

MUSEUM INNOVATIONS

BY: HANNAH MONKMAN

In trying to innovate or even just to stay relevant, museums often look to the latest technology to reach their goals. Personally, I love the idea of using virtual reality (VR) as a vehicle of interpretation in museums (noting that yes, virtual reality and augmented reality are different). I believe VR could be used to effectively immerse the visitor in a new environment and provide another level of engagement in an exhibit. Eager to see this in practice, I recently visited two museums in London, ON that both featured VR options in their exhibits through the use of an Oculus Rift.

Roadtrip!! Source.

The first museum I visited was the Royal Canadian Regiment Museum (RCRM), which included a VR experience that takes you into the Battle at Vimy Ridge. Unfortunately, I couldn't get this experience to work—whether the machine was broken, turned off, or the instructions on how to use it were simply unclear, it was definitely a disappointing moment of the visit. The second museum was the Museum of Ontario Archaeology (MOA), which featured a VR longhouse that visitors can explore.


The virtual reality booth with Oculus Rift headset at the Royal Canadian Regiment Museum. Photo courtesy of Hannah Monkman. 

These experiences emphasized some of the risks involved with using high-tech of any sort in an museum environment, and helped inform my understanding of using tech in museums. Here's a rundown of what I learned:

1. Digital technology generally requires specialized maintenance, and staff must be trained to troubleshoot any issues with the tech (especially if the creation of the tech was contracted to external companies). Whether that means simply turning it off and then on again, or fixing broken components, interactive components of displays should be working as often as possible. I visited the RCRM specifically to see the VR exhibit and was frustrated when it did not work. I felt that it was more disappointing to see the cool tech and then have it not work, than if they had not included the tech at all. If you don't have staff on hand who knows (or can learn) how to care for the outsourced tech, perhaps consider a less complex option.

Sometimes dealing with technology isn't as difficult as it may seem. Source.

2. Consider the ethical implications of your VR experience. The psychological impact and ethics related to virtual reality have not been studied much yet at this point. However, concerns have been voiced about the implications of inhabiting a virtual body along with the realistic levels of immersion VR experiences can offer. While I did not get to try the VR at the Regiment Museum, I do know that the experience takes the user to the front lines of the battle. Especially since the experience was designed specifically for grade school students, I question the ethics of such an experience—not that it will negatively affect all users, of course, but that it has the potential to do so since the explosions and gunshots are allegedly very realistic. The effects could be minimal, or be on opposite sides of the spectrum as the users become either desensitized to violence or traumatized in extreme cases due to their experience. Placing the user in the position of a soldier in a 4D virtual reality experience is very different from learning the content in other formats.

If simply watching a movie can affect how we perceive things like war, how would "living" it through VR affect us? Source.

3. Museums often have a habit of using tech for tech's sake—but this can be an ineffective way to engage your visitors. Before committing large amounts of resources to tech like VR, ask yourself: what is this adding to the exhibit? What am I trying to convey with this, and is it actually effective to use VR to do so? The virtual reality at MOA was interesting experience in VR, but less interesting in terms of the content. Walking through a longhouse and picking up objects within a 5 minute time limit provided no additional information for me, especially when physical longhouses were outside on museum grounds. Despite initially thinking that 5 minutes was not a very long time, I found myself running out of things to do or explore in the experience before it was over. After I finished, I found myself thinking, "Why is this here?" Especially since there was a small additional fee to use the VR here, it is definitely in the museum's best interest to make the visitor think it was worth it—whether they paid a few extra dollars or simply paid with their time.

So, while I stand firmly in the position that VR could be used as an incredibly effective way of interpreting content and engaging the visitor, museums have to be careful that they're not using technology like virtual reality "just because." Rather, it should be used because its unique qualities add something that couldn't be attained by another interpretive vehicle. Instead of chasing after the newest technologies, museums should focus on the interpretive potential and the resulting visitor experience when considering how to make exhibits innovative.

tldr; virtual reality has great innovative potential, but only with careful thought about the risks and benefits of using the technology. As long as you think it through and can justify using the tech, VR could be a great option for your museum.

With thorough consideration, you can definitely "follow your dreams" in innovative pursuits. Source.

1 May 2017

MEDIEVAL MURDER MYSTERY? RICHARD III AND HIS DISAPPEARING NEPHEWS

MUSEUM MYSTERIES

BY: SERENA YPELAAR

We’ve heard it said time and time again: history is written by the "victors". Those in power are at liberty to shape public perceptions and historical narratives. King Richard III of England's notoriously poor reputation is a prime example of the power of public memory. Richard III is infamous for the alleged murder of his young nephews in the Tower of London, and the unsolved mystery of their disappearance poses an interpretive challenge in the absence of hard evidence.

Late 16th century portrait of King Richard III
by an unknown artist, housed in the National
Portrait Gallery of London.
Source.
In 1485, only two years after his ascent to the throne, Richard III was killed at the Battle of Bosworth Field, effectively ending the Wars of the Roses. Richard the Yorkist was succeeded by his Lancastrian enemy Henry Tudor (later crowned Henry VII) and was buried without ceremony. 

To legitimize their claim to the throne, the Tudors engaged in a smear campaign against Richard III, and Tudor propaganda succeeded in tarnishing his character. Richard III’s reputation for unmatched tyranny has endured throughout the centuries, thanks in no small part to William Shakespeare’s ungenerous portrayal of the last Plantagenet king in his play Richard III.

While one Richard III mystery was solved in 2013 when the bones discovered under a Leicester car park were confirmed as Richard’s, another question still lingers: what really happened to his nephews, Edward V and Richard of Shrewsbury?

Though Richard III was reburied in 2015, the mystery of his nephews’ fate was not. In June 1483, when Richard was Lord Protector of the realm, his late brother King Edward IV’s marriage to Elizabeth Woodville was deemed invalid, making his two young heirs illegitimate. Twelve-year-old Edward V’s coronation never took place, and his uncle assumed the throne instead. Despite the fact that Richard’s nephews were ineligible for the throne, they disappeared in August of that year and were never seen again. Richard III is commonly believed to have murdered the boys; historical narratives by Robert Fabyan, Thomas More, and Polydore Vergil also implicate the late king. Indeed, Richard certainly had motive, as his accession to the throne was fragile and occurred during tumultuous times.

Paul Delaroche, The Death of the Sons of King Edward in the
Tower
(1830). This painting is currently at the Louvre in Paris.
Source.
While remodeling the Tower of London in 1674, workers found two small skeletons in a box buried under the staircase near the White Tower’s chapel. In 1933, Westminster Abbey’s archivist, Lawrence Tanner, anatomist Professor William Wright, and the president of the Dental Association, George Northcroft, examined the bones and established that they belonged to two children around the ages of the princes. In 1789 two separate, unidentified coffins were also found in St. George’s Chapel at Windsor Castle, but the remains within have not been tested.

Evidence against Richard III is circumstantial at best, and there is no proof that the boys were indeed murdered. The Church of England has not permitted DNA testing of the skeletons to concretely identify them as the sons of Edward IV (though this test would not prove cause of death). Historian Philippa Langley, who spearheaded the Looking For Richard project that resulted in the discovery of his remains in Leicester, hopes to solve the mystery of the princes with the help of cold case investigators. In this case, however, a concrete verdict may be unattainable. As Richard was away from court when the boys disappeared, confirming his involvement is extremely difficult. There is no evidence to prove that he ordered someone (such as courtier Sir James Tyrrell) to kill his nephews, though the possibility remains.

When giving tours, Yeoman Warders draw upon their storytelling skills to share stories of the Tower
of London's history. In the case of the Princes in the Tower, an age-old mystery, the details are murky. Source.
Interpreters at the Tower of London therefore tread carefully around the story of the princes’ deaths. In discussing the Bloody Tower, where the boys were purportedly imprisoned, Historic Royal Palaces can only provide a few facts and contextual information on the rumours surrounding the incident. How, then, do the Tower staff frame the disappearance of the princes without delving into speculation? Historic Royal Palaces commissioned the animation below to illustrate the disappearance of Richard III’s nephews without making false claims. However, due to the fact that the mystery is so widely popular, the video may serve to confirm visitors’ existing assumptions. Regardless, this rendition of the story uses nuanced interpretation to provide visual stimuli using the little information available.


Interpreting mysteries with little evidence is always difficult, and so too is the search for “the truth” in divisive histories. Perhaps the most controversial king in English history, Richard III inspires passionate opinions on the part of visitors and staff alike. The Tower of London takes a measured approach in the portrayal of past monarchs, as tyranny, violence, and deceit often characterized early English politics. Thus, Richard wasn't the only king to perform morally questionable acts, but the prevalence of the "Tudor Myth" made him an infamous figure. While Richard’s character has since been re-examined by contemporary historians, the mystery of the princes’ disappearance endures.

Without tangible evidence to prove whether Richard III murdered his nephews, interpreting the legend of the Princes in the Tower remains complex and limiting. Will we ever find out what really happened? Maybe. But ultimately, visitors continue to engage with the story partially because the truth is uncertain: the search for answers is often the most compelling part of the experience.

30 March 2017

A PAINT-STAKING PORTRAYAL: PAINTINGS AS HISTORICAL ARTIFACTS

THROWBACK THURSDAY

BY: SERENA YPELAAR

Recently, I’ve been thinking a lot about historical paintings and the question of accuracy. Whether I’m looking at famous portraits to picture what prominent figures looked like, or trying to imagine historical battles that took place before the advent of photography, historical paintings play a prominent role in visualizing history. 

As sources, paintings can certainly tell us a lot about a historical event or figure, but they also do a lot more than that: they communicate the values and ideals of any given time period in which a work was created.

Because the topic of historical paintings is unwieldly at best, I’ve decided to confine my examples to some early colonial paintings in Canada. Given that my undergraduate research focused on British and French colonialism from 1600 to 1830, I will explore the topic through the lens of early Canada. One of my favourite paintings of all time is The Death of General Wolfe (1770) by Benjamin West; not because I think it’s particularly accurate, but because it raises so many fascinating issues. 

The Death of General Wolfe by Benjamin West is a spectacular example of a sensationalized battle scene that raises more questions than it answers. Source. 
West’s 1770 painting depicts Major General James Wolfe dying at the Battle of the Plains of Abraham in 1759. Even without being an art history expert, I can recognize that West presents an idealized aesthetic of the scene, one that sensationalizes the battle and its outcome. The cost of a hard-won victory against a vastly larger French army (led by Louis-Joseph de Montcalm), Wolfe’s tragic death has been mythologized throughout the centuries.

The dramatic depiction of Wolfe as a fallen Christ-like figure, surrounded by onlookers, conveys the grandeur of the Neoclassical movement. West declared his own process in depicting the historical scene: “It must exhibit the event in a way to excite awe & veneration … all should be proportioned to the highest idea conceived of the Hero … A mere matter of fact will never produce this effect.”

West’s painting is laid out similarly to the Lamentation over the Dead Christ, painted by Anthony van Dyck c. 1630s. Since art is a form of interpretation and is constructed according to artistic conventions, additional context is relevant to visitors when situating the work in a history museum. Source.
Since artistic depictions of historical events take some license when constructing the scene, observing The Death of General Wolfe as a historical artifact prompts so many questions: What is happening here? Who are all these people? Who is the indigenous warrior at the bottom of the frame, and why is he depicted that way?

Asking these questions suggests missing context that could supplement the artwork with written interpretation in a history museum. At present, the Benjamin West painting hangs in the National Gallery of Canada, but if it were on display in the Canadian War Museum, for example, how would its significance differ? Arguably, the purpose of the artwork as a source changes when the object is placed in its new setting.

In a history museum, visitors are more likely to look for accurate depictions of historical events to gain a sound understanding of what happened in the past. This is where interpretation gets trickier, and museum professionals must make decisions on how best to exhibit artwork. Should the museum display related artifacts alongside the painting? Should there be a didactic panel specifically identifying differences between the historical event and its artistic depiction?

This painting by C.W. Jefferys, Champlain Trading with the Indians, does not reveal details on the quality of relationships between Champlain and Indigenous groups such as the Huron or Iroquois (neither of whom are explicitly identified in this artistic rendition). Source.
Especially when paintings deal with a contentious narrative, such as colonialism in Canada, explicit analysis is crucial. Factors such as the creator of the work, his or her purpose, and relevant biases can alter viewers’ understanding of a painting. C.W. Jefferys’ 1911 artwork, Champlain Trading with the Indians, lacks detail in the way of concrete information: the general term “Indian” is used in the title, overlooking the nuances of interaction in post-contact colonial New France. In this way, paintings can't stand alone as historical artifacts because they are missing the subtleties of cultural and historical significance.

The issue of accuracy is paramount in a setting where visitors have no photographs of a historical event, and constructed imagery is their main source of visual insight. More than an aesthetic experience, historical paintings have the power to convey not only emotion, but information that may be taken at face value. As such, clarity of interpretation provides an additional layer of context to ensure that these artifacts contribute to an accurate and informed view of the past.   

2 February 2017

SCENTS AND SENSIBILITY

MUSEUM INNOVATIONS

BY CASSY KIST

Museums have always been seeking new and interesting ways to tell history and stories. Whether that be through interactive digital components, images, objects, audio etc. - the list is endless. But lately I have been reading about multi-sensory exploration and how to some, especially curators touching is vital to understand and appreciate an object. However, another sense beyond hearing, seeing and touching has also been explored in museums and art pieces. Scents and smell have the potential to create not only excitement and intrigue, but also facilitate new forms of interpretation within museums. Scents tends to be excluded in history narratives and documented events, yet they are important details with the capacity to reveal aspects of time, space and context. If you recall a memory, maybe even walking down Bloor street, a multitude of smells will assault your conscious - maybe Chinese food, coffee or smoke; all these reveal something about the modern day Toronto city context.




Some Historians argue that scents even vanishing ones, are a pivotal part of history and should be preserved. Does that mean we should try to preserve the smell of the modern day theatre? Shopping mall or god forbid gym? Perhaps! While some scents might be unappealing they can reveal details related to time and place and thus, help narrate the tale of everyday life.

An after hours culture festival in the UK (Culture 24), encourages British museums to use scents at their events and in their exhibit spaces, allowing visitors to interact with museum objects in new and unique ways. According to Culture 24, you can animate collections with scent, alter perceptions and create opportunities for new interpretation. Furthermore, scents also create imagery, influence emotions and when shared between people, create connections and discussions.

But how can museums use or reconstruct scents to tell the tales of a historic past through exhibits and objects?

Source
One can look to the National Museum of Singapore for inspiration. The museum hired a perfume artist to create different scents that would bring to life their 700 Years exhibit by creating connections between visitors, the objects and their context pertaining to segments of Singapore’s history. Each era within the exhibit was complimented and encapsulated by 12 scents; one of these, a scent called Fear was fabricated out of musk and ammonia for the era representing Japanese occupation during WW2. Other scents such as the 8 Cent Meal, was created to represent the meals that social welfare departments handed out during the post-war years. This scent included passion fruit, coconut milk and vanilla beans; ingredients which the perfume artist researched in collaboration with the museum over 4-5 months.


Within the 700 years exhibit. Source

This added exhibit detail may cause complications if museums are to become serious in not only using scents but creating them. For example, what scents do curators use to enliven an exhibit and how do they decide which scent combinations will be an accurate representation? Staff may need to research the period, event or person they are representing and decide what scents will work to the advantage of the exhibit themes. Simple raw ingredients like cinnamon or musk might suffice or if representing a complex olfactory context, say perhaps an Egyptian ritual, one can consult an olfactory historian.

A what??? 

Olfactory historians are scholars who have researched scents that have been documented or referenced to over the past centuries. On the other hand, if wanting to compliment a display of Egyptian scent bottles, a curator may decide to use a 3,500-year-old perfume once worn by Pharaoh Hatshepsut and reconstructed by scientists and archaeologists.
At the end of the day no matter the research or choices that the curators make, visitor interpretation is always subjective. That being said, even if a scent doesn’t completely convey the curator’s intention, they can still connect people, place and things, bringing collections and narratives to life.

Of course with every new interaction there is always potential risks, such as how scents can affect objects and if they could cause collections to become inaccessible to people allergic to scents. Some scents might be naturally repugnant to some and interpretations of scents in relation to objects may distract from the exhibit themes.


Morrison smelling books (Source).
On the other hand there are people who are firm believers in the power of scent and their ability to not only entice reflection and discussion, but also give satisfaction. Ask Rachael Morrison who spent 3 years smelling books in the MoMA library as an art piece.

Source