Showing posts with label Queer Theory. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Queer Theory. Show all posts

13 July 2021

IN THE DARKROOM: EXPLORING TOM OF FINLAND'S ENDURING INFLUENCE


"Whenever I was depressed or disgusted, I would feel him, that spirit inside, urging me back to living, back to drawing, I believe there is a lot to the world that can’t be seen or touched, and if you turn away from that — especially if you are an artist — you are avoiding an important part of life, maybe the very heart of it.” - Tom of Finland


Tom Of Finland, Double Life Of The Gay Icon Who Changed A Nation -  Worldcrunch
Tom of Finland aka Touko Laaksonen 
Collage credit to Worldcrunch. Photo source.

Museums, be it local or international, are considered the arbiters of culture, keepers of history, and especially systems of representation. As an extension of such, exhibitions have become increasingly important to engage with many existing intersections of identity and to, in good faith, seek to advance conversations surrounding LGBTQ2+ iconography and representation in particular.


Fotografiska

My first grasp with queerness in the field of Museum Studies was with persons, both historical and contemporary: theorists like Judith Butler and artists such as Keith Haring, Mickalene Thomas, Catherine Opie, and my personal favourite, bisexual painter Tamara de Lempicka (I have a tattoo inspired by her work). The ArQuives, which was established to aid in the recovery and preservation of Canadian LGBTQ2+ histories, has also been a key window into queer museological knowledge, agency, and identities.

However, an artist I’ve always found to be equal parts seductive and intriguing throughout my experience as a Master of Museum Studies student is Tom of Finland (born Touko Laaksonen, 1920-1991). Though fairly characterized as graphic, provocative, and pornographic through his tangible association with kink and eroticism, his work is a refreshing reprieve from the puritanical Western art often kept by mainstream museums. Highly stylized and recognizable by muscled bodies, bulging appendages, leather fetish gear, and uniforms inspired by blue-collar workers and military men, Tom of Finland occupies a distinct, subversive space in the queer visual culture canon.

As someone with both an academic and personal interest in portraiture, I was even more enthralled with The Darkroom, a current exhibition (located in New York City, from April 30-August 20, 2021) that serves as an intimate look into the prolific artistry of Tom of Finland, curated by Berndt Arell of Fotografiska in collaboration with the Tom of Finland Foundation. As Pride 2021 celebrations looked a little different this year, The Darkroom is a fascinating way to engage with Tom of Finland’s 100 year legacy of queer art and never-before-seen, boundary-pushing, sexually powerful, homoerotic photographic portraits that served as references for his drawings.

Oppressed by the persecution of queerness in his native Finland, Laaksonen clandestinely photographed his muses/models as references for his drawings. They were kept under the cover of darkness and would become highly-coveted works in underground gay subcultures and communities. With the increasing openness found in the West, he would spend time in Los Angeles, where both freedom and his art were able to flourish. There, he would draw inspiration from American bodybuilding and develop a burgeoning interest in depicting Black men (some of his later illustrations would feature Black men and interracial sex scenes). This inclusion is doubly interesting, if not slightly problematic: Laaksonen had the general tendency to depict cis, white men, and more and more academics have touched on the hypermasculinization/hypersexualization and presence of Black men in visual culture. Though, it can be noted that, to some, he had helped to increase the visibility of "black gay male subjectivity" towards the culmination of the 20th century, the end of his career, to which critics characterize this period as his most overtly political. With Tom of Finland, all men were created equal.


Untitled, 1989. From Tom of Finland Foundation


Left to right: Untitled, 1984 (Val Martin); Untitled, 1986, Untitled, 1986 (above), Untitled, 1986 (below). Tom of Finland Permanent Collection
Untitled, 1984 (Val Martin); Untitled, 1986, Untitled, 1986 (above), Untitled, 1986 (below).

A statement from exhibition producer Jessica Jarl says, “To Fotografiska, this is a brilliant example of how photography – besides standing on its own – often plays a part in many different kinds of creating. The story of The Darkroom – the first art exhibition where Tom of Finland's photographs are also being shown – is in many ways a journey through time. From dark hidden rooms or parks, to open, well-lit salons. In some places, strong forces are now pushing this art – and the lifestyles it reflects – back into the darkness. One more reason to lift the importance of free art. And it feels right to have Tom's voice be heard.”

The very premise of this exhibition is born out of the sexually repressive environment of 1950s Finland. Laaksonen set up a darkroom in a closet of his home in Helsinki to develop the photographs he took. Not only racy and homoerotic, they were outlawed. The Darkroom displays his portraits on black walls with red accents; they are the star of the show, featuring hyper-masculine hunks, clad in uniforms or leather gear, all distended muscles and members. They act to fearlessly confront a system that even today continues to deny freedoms, legality, and basic rights to queer, gay, and trans communities — bringing to light the current relevancy of their struggle for liberation. 


’The Darkroom’, until 20 August, 2021, Fotografiska New York
Tom of Finland: 'The Darkroom'
Wallpaper

Even during the height of the AIDS crisis, Laaksonen continued to create positive images of gay culture, and in 1987, made a now-famous drawing encouraging the practice of safe sex. The title of the exhibition The Darkroom just feels so apt. To end off, here is a quote by longtime Whitney Museum curator Richard D. Marshall (Quoted in Ferguson, 2019) that illustrates the impact and significance of not only Tom of Finland's work, but also of the very concept of The Darkroom:

“Tom of Finland emerged in the 1950s to deliver us from the repressive, fearful, and disguised sexuality of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. Tom made the idealized male beauty of the Greek gods become contemporary, real living gods, with no judgmental distinction between active and passive sexual roles. Tom made the artificial Roman breastplate into lively skin and muscle; Tom made Christian sado-masochism positive, desirable, and enviable; Tom made Michelangelo’s saints naked and aggressive; Tom brought honest, ribald, consensual, enjoyable, and delirious male sexuality back into twentieth century art. (1997, p. 252)”

Suffice to say, as travel restrictions begin to lessen, I recommend visiting this exhibition if you’re interested in studies and imagery of sex positivity, masculinity, countering heteronormativity, queer culture, and unapologetic art. If you find yourself in New York City, go see for yourself.





Sources Referenced and Further Reading

Alan Sinfield (2004). On Sexuality and Power. Columbia University Press, https://doi.org/10.7312/sinf13408.

Leena-Maija Rossi (2019). From arousing drawings to art to behold: Tom of Finland’s long and winding road to the art world, Porn Studies, 6:4, 459-463, DOI: 10.1080/23268743.2019.1580450

Michael Ferguson (2019) Tom of Finland, Journal of Homosexuality, 66:6, 857-862, DOI: 10.1080/00918369.2018.1514206

Nicholas Boston (2021). The Photography of Tom of Finland. Gay City News, https://www.gaycitynews.com/tom-of-finland-photography-art/.

Thomson Reuters Institute (2020). Out of the Shadows: Remembering ‘Tom of Finland,’
https://www.thomsonreuters.com/en-us/posts/legal/tom-of-finland/.


15 February 2021

HOW TO TURN YOUR FIXATION ON AN OBSCURE MUSEUM IN ENGLAND INTO ACADEMIC RESEARCH: THE THESIS STREAM


Final Project Reflections | Caitlin McCurdy



This new Musings column will hopefully illuminate a road rarely walked down, and one I am currently venturing down: the MMSt thesis stream. First, let’s go over some basics. What is a thesis? Why do one? What am I doing? Here we go:

The basic requirements for the thesis stream include all the usual museum studies course requirements, in addition to INF1240 Research Methods or an independent reading course. The thesis itself is worth 2.0 credits, so keep that in mind while planning out your second year or you may end up taking 1.0 credit extra by accident.

The next step is to find a supervisor. Now what I did, was panic email the MMSt director unsure of where to start or how to even ask such a question of my professors. But it need not be a panic-inducing situation, after a quick meeting with the MMSt director, I was quickly pointed in the right direction, and found my co-supervisors Irina D. Mihalache and Patrick Keilty. At the start of Year 2, you submit your thesis proposal, and it is approved by Graduate Committee on Standing in early September. Most of the thesis work is done in the second year (that’s where I’m at). During Fall & Winter of your second year, you got to research, write, research, and also maybe write. More information can be found here


Petrie Museum of Egyptian Archaeology. Photo courtesy of Caitlin McCurdy.


What initially drew me to doing a thesis was an interest in exploring the connections and parallels in the development of three industries/ways of thinking that emerged in the 19th century: Egyptology, museums, and sexual classification. Honestly, it was a trip to England in February of 2018 that I credit (blame) for making me reconsider an Egyptology MA and instead shifting focus to museum studies.
My research centers a case study on the Petrie Museum of Egyptian Archaeology, a small university museum in London, England based out of University College London. I was entranced by a. the sheer volume of stuff they have and b. the direct ties to Egyptology founding figure and the museum’s namesake, William Flinders Petrie, and how the current museum is grappling with the shift in academic and popular thinking away from glorifying colonizers.

Me at the Petrie, circa 2018. 


Over the last year, this initial curiosity has grown and matured in an actual research framework with methodology and scope. There is a number of ancient Egyptian artifacts that can be considered erotic or lude, I’ve written about a few in my previous column, most notably this Temple Wall of Senwosret. Through research I did in my undergrad, I found that the erotic that was presumed onto these objects were sometime misplaced or a misinterpretation on the part of a modern scholar. Epistemologically, what does this mean for Egyptology as a field and museums as a place for safekeeping knowledge.

Ultimately, the question I am trying to answer is “How does historical knowing function erotically within ancient Egypt?”. Now, what does that actually mean I’m researching? Excellent question, I don’t know. But here’s what I’ve been reading for the last six months.

The foundational texts for my thesis are The Social Life of Things: Commodities in Cultural Perspective by Arjun Appadurai and Unpacking Culture: Art and Commodity in Colonial and Postcolonial Worlds by Ruth B. Phillips and Christopher B. Steiner. Through a Marxist framework informed by these books, I define 19th century Egyptology as a tournament of values, where Egyptian artifacts are reconfigured as commodities, with new meaning and value ascribed to them, which then alters their “biography”. This process effects any meaning making that has occurred since their initial removal from Egypt. So, my earlier question of what does erotic knowing look like in ancient Egypt may be more accurately written as how is this knowledge produced, and who is producing it?

I love a good chart!


Because I’m focusing on erotic artifacts, I knew eventually my research would lead me into the realm of queer theory. I had previously read some Foucault and David Halperin writings on how to historically study sex and sexuality but was unsure where to begin to tie such a framwork into my museological framework. One of my supervisors, Patrick Keilty, referred me to the writings of Elizabeth Freeman and Valerie Traub on erotohistoriography and Pete Sigal’s writings on Ethnopornography, which ultimately became the lens through which I will be studying my selected artifacts from the Petrie.

My current thinking is that colonial knowledge and commoditization create a “Victorian scrim”, raising questions of whose erotic experience is being interpreted, and whose erotic way of knowing is involved in erotohistoriography. Now that I have a framework and direction, my next step is some historical and archival research into the museum itself. This means searching through annual reports, archaeological field reports and various other publications. Wish me luck!

Next in this column, we’ll hear about what other theses the fine folks in the MMSt thesis stream are doing.


Exterior of the Petrie, the pizza shop next door provides a unique olfactory experience. Source

18 November 2020

ACT, IDENTITY, AND AN ANCIENT GREEK VASE

Object of the Week | Caitlin McCurdy


In all my articles for this column, I have shied away from talking about the Greeks and their plethora of erotic and nude artifacts that fill museum’s collections. I find their thousands years history rather daunting to tackle, and the complex homosocial, inter-generational sexual relationships between men that are equally well-documented even more so. But we’re opening that can of worms now, so let’s discuss this little pocket of history through this week’s object: an amphora from the British Museum’s collection, originally from Athens of Archaic Greece, circa 540 BCE.


Front side of an Archaic Greek Amphora (c) The Trustees of the British Museum | Source

Amphorai were typically used for the storage and transport of wine and food. To create black-figure pottery, a slip that turned black during firing was applied to the pottery in the shape of figures and ornamental motifs.

I first came across this artifact in a book called A Little Gay History by R.B. Parkinson. It’s a cute, quick look at same-sex desire across history, and an interesting read to see how this desire has manifested itself in material culture across time and civilizations. Parkinson discusses the culturally approved intimacy of boys & men in ancient Greece, how they were structured by age, and the inclusion of these relationships in scenes depicted on pottery.


Cover of R. B. Parkinson's Book. Courtesy of Caitlin McCurdy

Parkinson works as an Egyptology professor at Oxford University and is a former curator of the British Museum’s Department of Ancient Egypt and Sudan. He has written on the study of LGBT histories and ways in which to extend this historiography into ancient civilizations which carried different signifiers, gender roles, and meanings from our own. In an essay about his process for writing this book, he emphasized the potential social impact of engaging in the historiographic work. In other essays of his, he also describes the importance of not overextending modern labels and identities when studying behaviours and acts that feel familiar to our current moment, as in their original context they may have served a different purpose. As he states himself, “such historical interpretation is not a purely ‘academic’ matter, and research on such topics has to be irrefutably accurate or it risks a backward step.”

In my personal statement for admission to this program, I wrote that reaching into the past to find evidence of yourself can help legitimize your identity to a present that is looking for a reason to dismiss you. Museum exhibitions can help in this process, and I have had emotional moments in LGBT-themed exhibitions when confronted with effective framing of these artifacts. But it has to be done responsibly.

The treatment of these artifacts by the museums that hold them play an important part in how the public views the artifacts, and the people who created them. By framing the amphora within a context of same sex desire, questions of similarities between today's gay community and the pederastic relationships of ancient Greece come to mind.


Close Up on the British Museum Amphora. (c) The Trustees of the British Museum. Source.

The homosocial relationships between men in ancient Greece are often discussed as being early representations of gay relationships, and having the amphora included in exhibitions about LGBT identities and histories adopts this perspective. Parkinson also frames the amphora as representative in this way. As depicted in this vase, bearded men are courting younger athletic youth, reflecting how these pederastic relationships served a function unique to ancient Greece. When I asked my friend & resident ancient Greece expert Sydney Rodrigues about this phenomenon, she had the following to say:





But when are representations of same sex desires ever a quick conversation?

As my parasocial dream professor Dr. Parkinson wrote, “I myself am not a historian of sexuality, but simply a gay Egyptologist who specialises in Middle Kingdom literature from around 1900–1650 BC.” I currently don’t think of myself as a historian of sexuality, but I think that’s slowly changing as more and more of my thesis is looking into queer theory and applying it to museums and Egyptology. But I am a gay Egyptologist, and the instinct to look at ancient Egypt and find myself there has been present since my 101 essay on Women in Egypt.

I focus on erotic artifacts because I am fascinated by what they reveal about humanity. The two things that are consistent across all cultures, from ancient Greece and Egypt into Medieval Europe, are death and sex. And we know about death: the funerary cult of Egypt, the Catholic rites of 15th century England. But death is also stagnant, it remains buried and preserved, waiting to be uncovered. Sex is elusive, a set of actions rarely depicted in material culture, and even more difficult to preserve through centuries of Western society creating taboos around discussion of such material.

(c) The Trustees of the British Museum. Source.

This amphora is a glimpse into the life of ancient Greeks, both in its use to serve wine and its depictions of a moment of life — relationships between men. Currently, the online collections of the British Museum list the amphora as not on display, but it does have an extensive exhibition history. In 2018–2019 it was included in the Ashmolean Museum’s exhibition titled Desire, love and identity: exploring LGBTQ identities. A decade earlier, in 2007–2008, the amphora was part of an exhibition at the Barbican Centre in London called Seduced: Art and Sex from Antiquities to Now. 

I am intrigued by the moment when a gay man wanders into these exhibitions and peers into a display case to see this amphora. Does he see himself reflected back at him? Or is the art style too foreign, the cultural context too different from his own? Do the years of colonial interference alter his understanding of the artifact? This phenomenon is described by Elizabeth Freeman as erotohistoriography, a queer theory concept which is currently taking up a lot of real estate in my brain, and it has huge applicability for museums. Maybe by the time I’m finished this program I’ll have some answers to these questions. But more likely, I’ll continue to study the past, and look for myself there. 

21 July 2014

THESIS REFLECTION: 'QUEER' EXHIBITIONS?

BY: NICOLE RITCHIE

As many of you may know, WorldPride 2014 happened in Toronto this past June. This encouraged a wide variety of WorldPride funded, supported, and affiliated events, and, in particular, I was excited about the mass quantity of queer related arts and cultural events.

There were several events and exhibits that began before the WorldPride week in late June, while others are still continuing throughout the summer, including exhibits directly affiliated with WorldPride and ones that are just hopping on the queer summer bandwagon here in Toronto.

These events included a queered version of AGO’s First Thursdays entitled Fan the Flames: Queers on Fire, a queered version of Nuit Blanche entitled Nuit Rose, and even an exhibit co-curated by two of our very own Master of Museum Studies students entitled Archiving Public Sex.

Did anyone get a chance to check out any of the exhibits? I’d love to hear your thoughts! If not, don’t fret – there are several ‘queer’ exhibitions continuing this July and August. With my thesis, I may not be engaging directly with these exhibits or with a specific ‘queer’ exhibit, but I am constantly analyzing what ‘queer’ means for arts and cultural space. I would like to encourage you to attend one (or all!) of these exhibitions listed below, or any seemingly or self-proclaimed ‘queer’ exhibit in your vicinity and share with me your thoughts, criticisms, and opinions. In particular, I would like to engage in a dialogue in light of my previous posts on queer theory and my proposal to ‘queer’ museums, and how these existent and experiential spaces work within (or not) that frame of interrogation.

Wynne Neilly: Female to “Male”
July 23rd - August 24th
Student Gallery, Ryerson Image Centre
(article of note)


Wynne Neilly, January 24th 2014 – 24th Shot, 2014, Fuji Instax film

Just Me and Allah: Photographs of Queer Muslims
By Samra Habib
June 24th - October 5th
Canadian Lesbian and Gay Archives


Excerpt from an interview with Samira Mohyeddin for the Queer Muslim Project

Camp Fires: The Queer Baroque of Léopold L. Foulem, Paul Mathieu, and Richard Milette
May 29th - September 1st
Gardiner Museum
Tours Everyday at 2pm - FREE for students on Tuesdays

 Robin Metcalfe, Curator, discusses “What is Camp Fires?”

Side note: I particularly like this quote from The Varsity that is demonstrative of ‘camp’s potentialities to work in dialogue with the concept of ‘queer’ as identified in my queer theory 101 post:

“Apart from its affinity for the frivolous, camp can be summarized as a form of resistance against dominant order, concerned with challenging the social conventions that marginalize queer individuals and oppress queer cultures.”


To conclude, here are some questions that I have and continue to interrogate. They are just a sliver of my own queries in order to provoke your thoughts and criticisms.

Are exhibitions ‘queer’ simply because they (which, who even is ‘they’?) self-identify as ‘queer’? Are the exhibits ‘queer’ because they contain content that is affiliated with the LGBT movement? Is ‘queering’ fulfilled by filling a normative arts and cultural space with such ‘queer’ content’? To what extent does being financially supported by WorldPride, a corporate sponsored non-for-profit organization, affect said ‘queerness’? Does the space and experience of the exhibitions differ at all from normative exhibitions? What affective experiences are being promoted? What are the overarching messages or narratives of the exhibits for the LGBTQ community?

For my thesis, I pursue a broader understanding of the que(e)rying of arts and cultural space that is more in dialogue with the non-normative, albeit ideologically and discursively. I would, therefore, also encourage you to share, in dialogue with this post, your experiences of what you felt was a non-normative arts and cultural space or exhibit.

1 July 2014

THESIS REFLECTION: QUEER THEORY 101

BY: NICOLE RITCHIE

So what is queer theory? As outlined in my first post, my goal is to queer museums.  But, what does ‘queering’ even mean? 

In order to provide a general understanding of queer theory that will contextualize my future posts, I decided to dedicate a post to defining this field.  Like any attempt at briefly defining a major body of knowledge, I struggle to be brief and concise while not over simplifying. Therefore, please note that there are major gaps, oversights, and simplifications below, as well as a clear emphasis on the academic development of ‘queer theory’ rather than a history of the term ‘queer’ and queer identities/communities/activism.

Epistemology of the Closet Book Cover, by Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick

Queer theory emerged in the 1990s in the USA after the AIDS crisis, an event that greatly affected the feminist and gay communities and its politics.  Teresa de Lauretis is credited with first using ‘queer theory’ at a conference at UCSC in 1990.  The term, which has historically been used as slander, was, at that point, being reclaimed and adopted by a burgeoning body of academics and activists.  Most famously, Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick’s Epistemology of the Closet (1990) and Judith Butler’s Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of Identity (1990) are credited as the founding queer theory texts.  On the most basic level, these two texts interrogate the binary structure of heterosexuality and homosexuality and the culturally constructed performance of gender, respectively.  Sedgwick and Butler marked a move into questioning the social, cultural, and political structures and systems that both create and perpetuate those identities and activities seen as ‘non-normative’, and thus an interrogation of the ‘normative’.

Meme of Judith Butler
Meme of Judith Butler
In the last twenty-five years, the field has grown vastly.  Queer theory has been utilized as a lens in almost all disciplines from the humanities and social sciences to engineering and medicine. In order to provide a taste of the diverse definitions of ‘queer theory’, here are some brief quotes by several of the ‘big’ queer theorists.  There is also, by no means, an agreement as to what ‘queer’ means, what queer theory seeks, and what queer world-making entails.

In a Queer Time & Place book cover by Judith Halberstam

“…queer refers to nonnormative logics and organizations of community, sexual identity, embodiment, and activity in space and time” (6).

José Esteban Muñoz, Cruising Utopia: The Then and There of Queer Futurity (2009)

“Queerness is essentially about the rejection of a here and now and an insistence on potentiality or concrete possibility for another world” (1).

No Future book cover by Lee Edelman

“…queer must insist on disturbing, on queering, social organizations as such – on disturbing, therefore, and on queering ourselves and our investment in such organization.  For queerness can never define an identity; it can only ever disturb one.  And so, when I argue, as I am to do here, that the burden of queerness is to be located less in the assertion of an oppositional political identity than in opposition to politics as the governing fantasy realizing, in an always indefinite future…” (17). 

And what about ‘queer’ in our society today?  Generally, I would say that we think of the Q in the LGBTQ acronym, or the extended one of LGBTTIQQ2SA (lesbian, gay, bisexual, transsexual, transgender, intersex, queer, questioning, 2-spirited, and asexuality).  Queer is a growing ‘non-identity’ adopted by those not partaking in ‘normative’ labels or values or activities, such as genderqueer, pansexuality, or non-goal-oriented sexual practices. 

Thus, ‘queer’ has been taken up in both academic and community environments to a variety of ends.  Furthermore, I would like to note that I have not truly touched on various complexities of the relationship of queer theory with feminism, with queer activism, and more.

However, I will leave it at that – I recommend checking out this humorous article entitled “What the F@#$ is Queer Theory?”.  Hopefully, we can flush out some of these brief points and any further curiousities or comments about ‘queer’ in the comments, as well as elucidate my use of queer theory for my thesis in future posts!

10 June 2014

THESIS REFLECTION: THE WORLD OF CONFERENCES

BY: NICOLE RITCHIE

With an interest in pursuing doctoral studies, I have dived into the world of conferences, gaining experience in public speaking and exposure to the dynamic dialogues. The iSchool annual student conference and the newly developed MMSt panel at the CMA conference were both invaluable opportunities for myself!


However, you might be wondering – how does this relate to my thesis? Well, I recently attended the Berkshire Conference on the History of Women at U of T and the Sexuality Studies Association’s conference at Congress in St. Catharine’s, ON. Most prominently, my interest was piqued by a paper entitled “Queering Museums: Epic Fail”. Seeing as this is the project that I am just embarking on, this talk was both foreboding and exhilarating. You can imagine, I’m sure!

Special Session at the Sexuality Studies Association’s Conference

I chose these conferences because they had various panels about collecting on the edges and challenging museum and archival practices through asexuality, affect, and more.  I went on to feel stimulated, intimidated, disappointed, excited, and overwhelmed by attending discussions on topics that I am both engaging with as well as pursuing.  These are the people I want to be in conversation with, who are discussing the same sources, and who can provide me with innovative (and perhaps scarily similar and/or oppositional) ideas that directly affect my work and future goals.  I was nervous to explain my current project without knowing quite where I fit yet and where I was going.  What do I want to take away from these experiences into my research?

Train Ride from St. Catherine's ON
Reflecting on the train ride back from St. Catharine’s, ON
(I attended both of these conferences over a seven-day period, leading to many thoughts and feelings!)

Well, I have noticed that, even though I am just starting on this project, I am not super surprised by where these panels and papers went. In fact, I had hoped for something more groundbreaking. They discussed several things that I have and will interrogate in, hopefully, a much deeper and deconstructive way. And yet, there were also instances that triggered and highlighted areas and ideas to consider. My key discovery is that I have a major research topic that is deeply needed and present. There were underpinning notions within many of the talks that, I believe, need to be questioned, and now I am even more inspired to engage in those interrogations.


So is queering museums an epic fail? Well, I can’t actually share the example from that paper due to the confidentiality issues that prefaced the talk. But, the presentation did make clear that the neoliberal values embedded in the language of individual rights and freedoms have lived strong and true, censoring the proposed representation of diverse (minoritarian and non-normative) queer kinship formations in order to hold true to the queer liberalist celebration of same-sex marriage. While this instance, albeit by significant people at significant places, may have failed, where can we go with this? How can we question the underlying principles and structures of normative institutional systems of archives and museums? In what ways can we productively view such ‘failure’, particularly in relation to, rather than being a negative experience, the potentially queer power of such experiences (an argument that has been made by Jack Halberstam)? Furthermore, is not this failure categorized as such according to the institutional norms and structure? What is beyond this limited definition and dominant paradigm of failure (and success)?

20 May 2014

THESIS REFLECTION: QUEERING MUSEUMS

BY: NICOLE RITCHIE

My name is Nicole Ritchie, and I entered the Master of Museum Studies program in collaboration with Sexual Diversity Studies in September 2013.  As the third contributor to the thesis column this summer, I will give you a brief overview of my background and my research.

I graduated from the University of Alberta with a Bachelor of Arts with Distinction in Women’s Studies and Art History.  Throughout my undergrad, I volunteered at a variety of museums, galleries, and collections, which led to my interest in arts and cultural institutions and my application to the MMSt program.  This included collections management and curatorial work at the Clothing and Textile Collection at the University of Alberta, the Royal Alberta Museum, the Bata Shoe Museum, Lando Art Gallery and Auctions, and, currently, the Sexual Representation Collection. With this background in practical expertise intertwined with my love of feminist and queer theory, my thesis topic emerged.



My thesis will interrogate and conceptualize the theoretical foundation of non-normative – that is, values and ideas that do not uphold the dominant social system – arts and cultural space through the act of ‘queering’.  This will involve looking at several major academic bodies of literature – museum studies, queer theory, affect theory, and social and cultural geography studies.  I will engage with these fields, drawing innovative connections that contribute to both new theoretical dialogues as well as new possibilities for museum practice.  As well, I will engage with museums as participants within and tools of neoliberalism, which is a frame that, I believe, is valuable to interrogate in the context of queer theory – a field that insistently criticizes neoliberal values, such as that of normativity and inclusivity.  Throughout my thesis, I will reference various examples of museum practice to demonstrate current museum practices that either perpetuate a normative paradigm or develop a ‘queer’ space in order to enhance and highlight various aspects of my argument.  

This engagement will be guided by various themes that are reflected in my research questions:

  • How can queer and affect theory be utilized to think about non-normative arts and cultural space?  
  • How can these spaces be queered, and what does ‘queering’ accomplish for the theoretical development of museum identity and space and the potentialities of practice?  
  • In what ways do specific practices of museum studies, such as ‘difficult knowledge’, preservation, and commemoration, speak in dialogue with practices of queer theory, such as the formation of ‘archives’ and queer historiography? 

My project is significant for engaging museology in dialogue with queer theory, affect theory, and theories of social and cultural geography, but also for the development of non-normative museum methods, practices, and experiences that reflect the growing contemporary discussion of ‘queer’ in society. 

My thesis committee is composed of a communications and museum studies scholar, Dr. Irina Mihalache, and a feminist and queer technology studies scholar, Dr. Patrick Keilty.  Thus, my committee forms a dynamic and well-rounded grouping in order to support my diverse interests and fields of research.    

Now here’s to executing this!  Stay tuned for my progress on June 9th!