Showing posts with label biodiversity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label biodiversity. Show all posts

14 February 2020

TEACHING CLIMATE CHANGE PART III: LEARNING BY EXAMPLE

Museums on Earth | Defne Inceoglu

Illustration courtesy of Defne Inceoglu.
Last time, we talked about language and need - using research done at the Royal Ontario Museum. For Part III of this series, we will explore other institutions who are using their natural history collections to teach about climate change.

\\\

Natural history museums stand as a legacy to the 18th and 19th centuries. Classifying and actively collecting specimens has carried through from the past two hundred years, imbuing many museums with large collections of animals. (I wrote about birds in a museum collection over the Summer of 2019 - find the article here). These specimens sit in collections or in displays across many institutions, which has always left me wondering about the role that these complicated objects play in the 21st century. 

Some museums, like the Royal Ontario Museum (ROM), have re-purposed their collection to teach climate change. The Schad Gallery of Biodiversity groups animals into ecosystems and discusses human impact on the environment.

There is good intent with an idea such as this: show off the natural world in order to create interest and advocacy. If a person visits a museum and sees a polar bear, will they be inclined to do something to save them? 

Exhibition view from nanoq: flat out and bluesome. Artists
Bryndís Snæbjörnsdóttir and Mark Wilson: (Source).


Does the visitor here need something extra, like a didactic or interactive element which will tell them how the polar bear is at risk?

Or will they be able to make the connection on their own?

Is a visitor as affected by a small rodent at risk than they are at a whale skeleton?

How do visitors give meaning or value to the objects they are seeing, what is impactful and how do they take away information?

These questions are always spinning around in my head as I go through the effectiveness of using an animal specimen or taxidermy to teach visitors about climate change. I only have the ROM's example to go by, so I decided to take a look at other big natural history institutions to see how they are using their collections to tackle this area of education.

I will highlight three institutions that have created climate-focused exhibitions or resources for visitors, all just in the past couple years. 

I. Natural History Museum at South Kensington (London, England)

An illustration showing a sign that reads 'yes you can'.
This ADORABLE illustration is from the Natural History Museum's article on how to live sustainably: Source.
   
The Museum has declared a planetary emergency, in recognition of humanity's failure to combat our destructive impact on the planet's survival systems. 
Climate change, biodiversity loss, habitat destruction, pollution and deforestation are just some of the crises caused by unsustainable human activity. These add up to an emergency on a planetary scale.
The museum has also worked in climate advocacy into their strategic plan.
Five strategic priorities will be at the core of the Museum's activities until 2031: 
1. securing the future of the collection  
2. transforming the study of natural history
3. developing the gardens and galleries
4. creating a resilient and sustainable organisation  
5. engaging and involving the widest possible audience  
The museum has also provided resources for visitors to their website on how they can make individual impacts. By giving their audience resources, the museum is really coming through for their visitors.

II. American Museum of Natural History (New York City, USA)

The American Museum of Natural history re-imagined their Hall of Planet Earth in 2018. In an official press release, they write:
The American Museum of Natural History is re-opening its climate change exhibit in the David S. and Ruth L. Gottesman Hall of Planet Earth with comprehensive updates to a section about one of the most urgent scientific issues of our time. The new installation, which opens to the public on Saturday, July 7, is anchored by a dynamic media wall featuring large-scale imagery, animations, text and graphics, and interactive panels where visitors can engage with the evidence for climate change. Updates, which have been in planning and development since 2016, also include new content in the hall’s sections on past climates as well as on convection.
Exhibition view of "What Causes Climate Change" component of the new gallery. "The climate change section features a media wall comprised of 36 high-definition 55-inch screens with “big-picture” messages about climate change. Below them, content panels and interactive stations based on data from organizations including NASA and NOAA (the National Oceanic Atmospheric Administration) explore three main themes: How Climate Works, Our Warming World, and Consequences of Climate Change": (Source).

In addition to their new hall, their biodiversity permanent exhibition contains information for visitors on how biodiversity is in jeopardy.


                                        III. University of Oslo: Natural History Museum

The University of Oslo's Natural History Museum is opening what they are calling a "Climate House" in their botanical garden section.
The Climate House opens in the Botanical gardens in Oslo spring 2020. The Climate House will be a new and exciting arena for communicating research on climate and environmental issues. Children, teenagers and their whole families will be able to learn more about what climate change means, to get to know the several solutions that exist and to get inspired towards action. From early morning until late at night, the Climate House will showcase research-based exhibitions, lectures, films and debates.
This approach caught my attention, as it is programming-focused rather than re-purposing their collection.

It's always good to learn by example. By researching other institutions that are doing work in climate education, we can select and learn new strategies for our own work. That being said, there are still lots of areas to improve in and grow. It is important to consider how the above three institutional strategies could be combined or adjusted - this tapestry of opportunity is still in the works. It's good to start keeping it in mind.


\\\


Check out the Coalition of Museums for Climate Justice, an active group that brings together museum professionals tackling the crisis.

Next time, let's chat more about obstacles and roadblocks.

15 January 2020

TEACHING CLIMATE CHANGE PART II: LANGUAGE & NEED

Museums on Earth | Defne Inceoglu


Illustration courtesy of Defne Inceoglu.

\\\

In Part I of this column, we discussed the necessary politicization of museums that plan to tackle the subject of climate change. In Part II, we will look over how language affects learning and begin to address the needs of visitors.

\\\

Over the months of October and November, I undertook a visitor research project at the Royal Ontario Museum (ROM), where I conducted 100 anonymous interviews with visitors of varying demographics within the Life in Crisis: Schad Gallery of Biodiversity. The intention of this research was to inform my thesis work, which is interested in analyzing what exactly is the relationship between the halls of biodiversity galleries, the stuffed animals which inhabit them and the visitor who walks through them. What sort of takeaway is a biodiversity gallery that is focused on overarching themes related to a global ‘life in crisis’? How does the visitor see this; what do they look at or absorb and how do they relay what they've learned? 

An area of the Biodiversity Gallery which has stark climate change messaging. Photograph courtesy of Defne Inceoglu.


A didactic in the gallery which details the human
impact on Great Lakes ecosystems. Photograph courtesy
of Defne Inceoglu.



LANGUAGE 

Immediately, the idea of the language or the semiotics of climate change related displays created contention. It occurred to me that using a term like ‘climate change’ is not interchangeable with other concepts such as ‘deforestation’, ‘ocean acidification’, ‘habitat loss’ – among other things. The assumption that climate change would act as an umbrella term for most visitors ended up being false. Further to this, it appeared as though visitors at the ROM do not completely correlate or group these sorts of globally-scaled events like mass habitat loss or extinction with the idea of climate change. Language, then, plays an important role in creating climate change awareness and education.





Of the 99 participants who answered the question “in your own words, what was the exhibition trying to show?” – only 7 people outright mentioned climate change as a major theme in the Biodiversity Gallery. This small number however does not represent a gap in understanding of the exhibition’s themes -- rather it represents a wide variety of understanding, again enforcing the idea that there is more meaning-making going on than meets the eye. 

A portion of a display case in the gallery, detailing life
in the Great Lakes. Photograph courtesy of
Defne Inceoglu. 
When asked the question, some visitors replied:

“Endangered species. [Humans are] destructive to habitat(s)”. 
[Participant 13, aged 25-34, Ontario resident]. 

“Reminds us of nature, what was here before us”. [Participant 38, aged 25-34, Toronto resident].

“We’re losing things that were alive when I was a child. Urgency is accelerating”. 
[Participant 54, aged 45+, BC resident].

“Trying to show us nature and making us realize we are out there in the world. In our hands to see if these creatures are protected or destroyed”. 
[Participant 78, aged 35-44, Mississauga resident].





These four participants, while giving answers unrelated in terminology to climate change, demonstrate that the exhibition offered to them a divergent understanding. Here then, we see where the gaps emerge. A low percentage of visitors picked up on the explicit climate change message, opting instead to mention personal anecdotes or speak directly to a non-specific or generalized 'negative' human impact. This is a good start, and shows that visitors are in fact engaged and relating the content back to themselves in a way. However, we can now consider language as a barrier to universal understanding and we must shrug off the assumption that all visitors relate-to and can speak-to climate change terminology. Instead, we have to listen to our audiences and connect to what is really being asked for. 

NEED

When asked, "Do you have anything else you would like to share with me? Be they concerns or praises?" some visitors replied:

"Nice exhibit. Not a lot of actions steps, doom and gloom; what can you do? Missed opportunity". [Participant 51, aged 25-34, US resident].

"Needs stuff more prescriptive and non-intimidating. Small steps people can take".
[Participant 66, aged 25-34, Toronto resident].

"What is climate change, what are some of the effects, actually explaining it. The science, the challenge, [is it] attainable?"
[Participant 68, aged 45+, New York resident]. 

The arctic display case in the gallery. Photograph courtesy of
Defne Inceoglu.
I want to address this area of need. We took a long look at the language discrepancies that visitors presented. Now we see a request, a demand or want. Teaching hard-to-digest topics to museum visitors can be daunting, and discovering what visitors are looking for is a way to ensure that your messages are communicated effectively. In the ROM's case, it is clear that visitors are seeking out tangible, attainable action and information. This discovery is crucial in understanding how we can begin to create a running dialogue which will both educate, un-intimidate and invigorate visitors.



///

Next time, we'll cover a few different international institutions and their efforts in creating climate awareness using a biodiversity collection.

I did not go into detail on my research methods -- if you have questions please reach out through a comment and I can get back to you with more information.

This research was conducted with deep gratitude to the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council for funding. The human research component of the project is approved by the University of Toronto's Research Ethics Board.