Showing posts with label Defne Inceoglu. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Defne Inceoglu. Show all posts

18 March 2020

TEACHING CLIMATE CHANGE PART IV: ROADBLOCKS AND OBSTACLES

Museums on Earth | Defne Inceoglu



Illustration courtesy of Defne Inceoglu.

Last time, we looked at examples of how international museums are speaking to the crisis. On this, my last post for Museums on Earth, I wanted to spend some time thinking about what sorts of obstacles lay ahead for museums.

\\\

Please reflect on your past and current public engagement on climate change. Your work matters, and it matters that we all perform at new levels. Allow these examples to embolden you to reach farther and to advocate in your organization, and in the field, for similarly creative and ambitious projects, then please share your learning and results widely. We must all learn and share as much as we can, as fast as we can, to create scalable and scaled change in ways that support and repair our climate. We must work at a rate never before attempted.
Sarah Sutton and Cynthia Robinson, "Museums and Public Climate Action" in the Journal of Museum Education vol. 45 (January 2020): 3.


The Journal of Museum Education's (JME) latest issue is dedicated to Museums and Climate Change - another addition of growing scholarship around museum and climate action. 

I close this chapter with more questions than answers. It is, of course, important to ask questions. Questions lead to problem-solving, discussion and action. Without addressing some very core issues, we risk overlooking issues or embracing naivety. 

I identify the following four issues below that I believe, through my research, to be the main obstacles that museums will face going forward:

Obstacle 1 |  Fighting apathy

Obstacle 2 | Funding and donorship

Obstacle 3 | Teaching accessible science-literacy

Obstacle 4 | Moving away from neutrality 


1 | Fighting apathy

It is important to address apathy. From my visitor research at the Royal Ontario Museum, I noted that visitors do not feel invigorated to take climate action if they are burdened with the sort of esoteric or existential reality of climate change. This, I claim, can lead people to apathy. One way to combat this is to ensure that our exhibits and programming focus more on local, community efforts - meetups, conversations, panels, presentations, interactive outings facilitated by the museum, etc. This sort of programming can look like a lot of things - however integrating more social action and conversation, as well as providing tangible resources for visitors. I think this is a large challenge, as the ability to create ongoing engagement and enrichment for visitors is sometimes a coin toss. Talk to your audience, your visitors - see what they want to see the museum doing - bring in new voices. Focus on real efforts being made by community groups and members in your cities and towns. 

This graph, based on the comparison of atmospheric samples contained in ice cores and more recent direct  measurements, provides evidence that atmospheric CO2 has increased  since the Industrial Revolution.  (Source: [[LINK||http://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/paleo/icecore/||NOAA]])
This graph, based on the comparison of atmospheric samples contained in ice cores and more recent direct measurements, provides evidence that atmospheric CO2 has increased since the Industrial Revolution. (Credit: Luthi, D., et al.. 2008; Etheridge, D.M., et al. 2010; Vostok ice core data/J.R. Petit et al.; NOAA Mauna Loa CO2 record.) Image courtesy of NASA's climate change website.

2 | Funding and donorship

Funding is always an uncertainty. Museum fundraising is tricky and complicated (as Samantha's column (Fun)draising for Musings spends time talking about). How do you invigorate your donors to support new, climate-focused exhibits or programming? Your institutions may not necessarily be science-oriented - art museums, galleries, historic houses, etc., can have different types of fundraising or donorship strategies that don't include convincing stakeholders to fund climate-focused content. 


Sea level rise is caused primarily by two factors related to global warming: the added water from melting ice sheets and glaciers and the expansion of seawater as it warms. The first graph tracks the change in sea level since 1993 as observed by satellites. This satellite data shows that the average sea levels rise 3.3 millimetres per year. Image courtesy of NASA.

3 | Teaching accessible science-literacy

Literacy matters, accessibility matters, and equity matters. If the content of your exhibitions is difficult to interpret, or if you do not provide a baseline for visitors, it can quickly become confusing or irrelevant. Science-literacy is not just about understanding graphs or subscribing to journals - you cannot expect all visitors to your museum to have these skills or wants. Instead, focus on taking steps to understand where visitors are coming from and what their education levels are. This way, you can tailor your content. It doesn't hurt to test your content, either. 

Take the Royal Ontario Museum's Blue Whale exhibition, which ran from March-September 2017. This exhibition was enormously popular - utilizing storytelling and community strategies to create a successful exhibit. 

This chart is what I am getting at: accessible information, explanation and resources for further research. Phew! Image courtesy of NASA.


4 |  Moving away from neutrality 

It is impossible to assume that you can achieve neutrality when talking about climate change. I talked about this in Part I, and as the months have passed it has really dawned on me that taking a stance, challenging visitors, and backing up your work with up to date literature and science is the only way to truly invigorate real change. 

///

That's all, folks! Stay safe out there. 

14 February 2020

TEACHING CLIMATE CHANGE PART III: LEARNING BY EXAMPLE

Museums on Earth | Defne Inceoglu

Illustration courtesy of Defne Inceoglu.
Last time, we talked about language and need - using research done at the Royal Ontario Museum. For Part III of this series, we will explore other institutions who are using their natural history collections to teach about climate change.

\\\

Natural history museums stand as a legacy to the 18th and 19th centuries. Classifying and actively collecting specimens has carried through from the past two hundred years, imbuing many museums with large collections of animals. (I wrote about birds in a museum collection over the Summer of 2019 - find the article here). These specimens sit in collections or in displays across many institutions, which has always left me wondering about the role that these complicated objects play in the 21st century. 

Some museums, like the Royal Ontario Museum (ROM), have re-purposed their collection to teach climate change. The Schad Gallery of Biodiversity groups animals into ecosystems and discusses human impact on the environment.

There is good intent with an idea such as this: show off the natural world in order to create interest and advocacy. If a person visits a museum and sees a polar bear, will they be inclined to do something to save them? 

Exhibition view from nanoq: flat out and bluesome. Artists
Bryndís Snæbjörnsdóttir and Mark Wilson: (Source).


Does the visitor here need something extra, like a didactic or interactive element which will tell them how the polar bear is at risk?

Or will they be able to make the connection on their own?

Is a visitor as affected by a small rodent at risk than they are at a whale skeleton?

How do visitors give meaning or value to the objects they are seeing, what is impactful and how do they take away information?

These questions are always spinning around in my head as I go through the effectiveness of using an animal specimen or taxidermy to teach visitors about climate change. I only have the ROM's example to go by, so I decided to take a look at other big natural history institutions to see how they are using their collections to tackle this area of education.

I will highlight three institutions that have created climate-focused exhibitions or resources for visitors, all just in the past couple years. 

I. Natural History Museum at South Kensington (London, England)

An illustration showing a sign that reads 'yes you can'.
This ADORABLE illustration is from the Natural History Museum's article on how to live sustainably: Source.
   
The Museum has declared a planetary emergency, in recognition of humanity's failure to combat our destructive impact on the planet's survival systems. 
Climate change, biodiversity loss, habitat destruction, pollution and deforestation are just some of the crises caused by unsustainable human activity. These add up to an emergency on a planetary scale.
The museum has also worked in climate advocacy into their strategic plan.
Five strategic priorities will be at the core of the Museum's activities until 2031: 
1. securing the future of the collection  
2. transforming the study of natural history
3. developing the gardens and galleries
4. creating a resilient and sustainable organisation  
5. engaging and involving the widest possible audience  
The museum has also provided resources for visitors to their website on how they can make individual impacts. By giving their audience resources, the museum is really coming through for their visitors.

II. American Museum of Natural History (New York City, USA)

The American Museum of Natural history re-imagined their Hall of Planet Earth in 2018. In an official press release, they write:
The American Museum of Natural History is re-opening its climate change exhibit in the David S. and Ruth L. Gottesman Hall of Planet Earth with comprehensive updates to a section about one of the most urgent scientific issues of our time. The new installation, which opens to the public on Saturday, July 7, is anchored by a dynamic media wall featuring large-scale imagery, animations, text and graphics, and interactive panels where visitors can engage with the evidence for climate change. Updates, which have been in planning and development since 2016, also include new content in the hall’s sections on past climates as well as on convection.
Exhibition view of "What Causes Climate Change" component of the new gallery. "The climate change section features a media wall comprised of 36 high-definition 55-inch screens with “big-picture” messages about climate change. Below them, content panels and interactive stations based on data from organizations including NASA and NOAA (the National Oceanic Atmospheric Administration) explore three main themes: How Climate Works, Our Warming World, and Consequences of Climate Change": (Source).

In addition to their new hall, their biodiversity permanent exhibition contains information for visitors on how biodiversity is in jeopardy.


                                        III. University of Oslo: Natural History Museum

The University of Oslo's Natural History Museum is opening what they are calling a "Climate House" in their botanical garden section.
The Climate House opens in the Botanical gardens in Oslo spring 2020. The Climate House will be a new and exciting arena for communicating research on climate and environmental issues. Children, teenagers and their whole families will be able to learn more about what climate change means, to get to know the several solutions that exist and to get inspired towards action. From early morning until late at night, the Climate House will showcase research-based exhibitions, lectures, films and debates.
This approach caught my attention, as it is programming-focused rather than re-purposing their collection.

It's always good to learn by example. By researching other institutions that are doing work in climate education, we can select and learn new strategies for our own work. That being said, there are still lots of areas to improve in and grow. It is important to consider how the above three institutional strategies could be combined or adjusted - this tapestry of opportunity is still in the works. It's good to start keeping it in mind.


\\\


Check out the Coalition of Museums for Climate Justice, an active group that brings together museum professionals tackling the crisis.

Next time, let's chat more about obstacles and roadblocks.

15 January 2020

TEACHING CLIMATE CHANGE PART II: LANGUAGE & NEED

Museums on Earth | Defne Inceoglu


Illustration courtesy of Defne Inceoglu.

\\\

In Part I of this column, we discussed the necessary politicization of museums that plan to tackle the subject of climate change. In Part II, we will look over how language affects learning and begin to address the needs of visitors.

\\\

Over the months of October and November, I undertook a visitor research project at the Royal Ontario Museum (ROM), where I conducted 100 anonymous interviews with visitors of varying demographics within the Life in Crisis: Schad Gallery of Biodiversity. The intention of this research was to inform my thesis work, which is interested in analyzing what exactly is the relationship between the halls of biodiversity galleries, the stuffed animals which inhabit them and the visitor who walks through them. What sort of takeaway is a biodiversity gallery that is focused on overarching themes related to a global ‘life in crisis’? How does the visitor see this; what do they look at or absorb and how do they relay what they've learned? 

An area of the Biodiversity Gallery which has stark climate change messaging. Photograph courtesy of Defne Inceoglu.


A didactic in the gallery which details the human
impact on Great Lakes ecosystems. Photograph courtesy
of Defne Inceoglu.



LANGUAGE 

Immediately, the idea of the language or the semiotics of climate change related displays created contention. It occurred to me that using a term like ‘climate change’ is not interchangeable with other concepts such as ‘deforestation’, ‘ocean acidification’, ‘habitat loss’ – among other things. The assumption that climate change would act as an umbrella term for most visitors ended up being false. Further to this, it appeared as though visitors at the ROM do not completely correlate or group these sorts of globally-scaled events like mass habitat loss or extinction with the idea of climate change. Language, then, plays an important role in creating climate change awareness and education.





Of the 99 participants who answered the question “in your own words, what was the exhibition trying to show?” – only 7 people outright mentioned climate change as a major theme in the Biodiversity Gallery. This small number however does not represent a gap in understanding of the exhibition’s themes -- rather it represents a wide variety of understanding, again enforcing the idea that there is more meaning-making going on than meets the eye. 

A portion of a display case in the gallery, detailing life
in the Great Lakes. Photograph courtesy of
Defne Inceoglu. 
When asked the question, some visitors replied:

“Endangered species. [Humans are] destructive to habitat(s)”. 
[Participant 13, aged 25-34, Ontario resident]. 

“Reminds us of nature, what was here before us”. [Participant 38, aged 25-34, Toronto resident].

“We’re losing things that were alive when I was a child. Urgency is accelerating”. 
[Participant 54, aged 45+, BC resident].

“Trying to show us nature and making us realize we are out there in the world. In our hands to see if these creatures are protected or destroyed”. 
[Participant 78, aged 35-44, Mississauga resident].





These four participants, while giving answers unrelated in terminology to climate change, demonstrate that the exhibition offered to them a divergent understanding. Here then, we see where the gaps emerge. A low percentage of visitors picked up on the explicit climate change message, opting instead to mention personal anecdotes or speak directly to a non-specific or generalized 'negative' human impact. This is a good start, and shows that visitors are in fact engaged and relating the content back to themselves in a way. However, we can now consider language as a barrier to universal understanding and we must shrug off the assumption that all visitors relate-to and can speak-to climate change terminology. Instead, we have to listen to our audiences and connect to what is really being asked for. 

NEED

When asked, "Do you have anything else you would like to share with me? Be they concerns or praises?" some visitors replied:

"Nice exhibit. Not a lot of actions steps, doom and gloom; what can you do? Missed opportunity". [Participant 51, aged 25-34, US resident].

"Needs stuff more prescriptive and non-intimidating. Small steps people can take".
[Participant 66, aged 25-34, Toronto resident].

"What is climate change, what are some of the effects, actually explaining it. The science, the challenge, [is it] attainable?"
[Participant 68, aged 45+, New York resident]. 

The arctic display case in the gallery. Photograph courtesy of
Defne Inceoglu.
I want to address this area of need. We took a long look at the language discrepancies that visitors presented. Now we see a request, a demand or want. Teaching hard-to-digest topics to museum visitors can be daunting, and discovering what visitors are looking for is a way to ensure that your messages are communicated effectively. In the ROM's case, it is clear that visitors are seeking out tangible, attainable action and information. This discovery is crucial in understanding how we can begin to create a running dialogue which will both educate, un-intimidate and invigorate visitors.



///

Next time, we'll cover a few different international institutions and their efforts in creating climate awareness using a biodiversity collection.

I did not go into detail on my research methods -- if you have questions please reach out through a comment and I can get back to you with more information.

This research was conducted with deep gratitude to the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council for funding. The human research component of the project is approved by the University of Toronto's Research Ethics Board.

5 December 2019

TEACHING CLIMATE CHANGE PART I: THE POLITICIZATION OF CLIMATE CHANGE OPINION IN CANADA

Museums on Earth | Defne Inceoglu



Illustration courtesy of Defne Inceoglu.

\\\

This is the beginning of a series on teaching climate change in museums. In this first article, I will be addressing the political divides that influence public opinion on climate change and where the Canadian public's minds may lie. This in turn can influence our audiences opinions - and may create conflict - within our museum spaces. Because of this, we must contend with the idea that we need to politicize our museum spaces in order to fulfill any future mandates based on education, truth, trust and advocacy.

\\\

There is really no sort of global topic as pressing or urgent than the current climate crisis. It is entrenched in the public’s psyche from media outlets reporting on unusual weather, droughts and floods. It is in the discussions amongst our world leaders and political parties; with whole political platforms dedicated to reducing carbon emissions and creating new policies and taxations.

The climate crisis has also made out to guilt the individual consumer: from companies greenwashing products to viral videos of sea animals suffering at the hands of plastic pollution.

On top of all of this, there is also the overwhelming pressure from the scientific community fighting just to be heard - one particular story which came out in the science journal Nature this past September, "‘Ecological grief’ grips scientists witnessing Great Barrier Reef’s decline", discusses the emotional toll that ecosystem researchers feel when witnessing decline.
"An emerging body of research shows that many people feel loss due to environmental degradation caused by global warming, a phenomenon called ‘ecological grief’. Although researchers are often on the front lines of ecosystem collapse, few studies have investigated the mental and emotional consequences of such work" (Source).
This emotional burden of the climate crisis is felt across all sides of the political spectrum; it is permeated into our everyday lives. A number of recent studies have been published on the psychological and physiological effects of climate change; unfortunately many of these studies are walled up and kept away from the public by expensive journal subscription fees. Having open access to these journals is a luxury that maybe only university students or faculty members can take for granted- such studies have only been touched few and far between by media.

This barrier of knowledge leaves publics to learn about climate change studies only from media sources - or the public are left to scour for sources on their own. Publics who find science inaccessible or uninteresting will presumably not look to primary source material. Not to mention these sorts of studies are upsetting and hard to stomach. This is not necessarily something someone would subject themselves to on purpose, especially considering that most people are burdened already with debt, physical/mental health issues, interpersonal relationships and work.

Additionally, the politics of this country are ever polarized and becoming more so still. This can be seen in our last election, but also tellingly in a 2011-2016 study that the Université de Montréal undertook in partnership with the Yale Program on Climate Change Communication, the University of California Santa Barbara and Utah State University. It is a study that has really stuck with me as I have been thinking through Canadian perspectives on climate change. The only criticism I have of this study is that it does not include any participants from the Territories or Labrador, seriously under-representing a large population of residents.

It is a project really unmatched and unparalleled in its scale in Canada, (with a sample size of almost 10,000 people), the researchers deduced by riding the climate change beliefs held by Canadians. The maps really speak for themselves; most surprisingly the statistic that only 60% of Canadians believe that the earth is getting warmer due to human interventions.

Below are three maps of interest that I pulled out of the study:


Image used with permission from the Université de Montréal's website. (Source).
Image used with permission from the Université de Montréal's website. (Source).

Image used with permission from the Université de Montréal's website. (Source).
Compare these maps to the 2019 election results by riding, and a pattern emerges:



Image courtesy of  CTV News' election coverage. (Source).


There is clear tension between our provinces in terms of political beliefs- mapped now into this is the question of climate change.

The question lies then, how do museums factor into all of this?

What is the role of the museum, or the responsibility of one, to discuss climate change? Can we use our spaces to discuss this – should we tackle this issue, keeping in mind the divided opinions and beliefs of the Canadian public - who are in turn our audiences?

To create exhibitions or facilitate programming with the intent on teaching or advocating for climate action, climate change in your institution will automatically destabilize any notion of the museum as apolitical. Instead, it will be invigorated with choice and conflict: with your museum audience divided by politics around policy, oil, taxation and climate change apathy.

\\\

Next time, we'll cover some strategies for talking with visitors about climate change, using my visitor research project at the Royal Ontario Museum as a case study.

15 October 2019

RISKY BEHAVIOUR IS 'STICKING TO THE STATUS QUO': CLIMATE STRIKES AND MUSEUM FUTURES WITH DOUGLAS WORTS



Illustration courtesy of Defne Inceoglu.
On September 27th 2019, people around the world gathered and rallied for action on the global climate crisis.

Simultaneously, Museum Studies alumni, faculty members and students were celebrating the 50th year as a program with the Unconference. (Read Jordan Fee’s in-depth summary of the day here). It was emphasized to us in the morning that if any attendees wished to leave to join the march at Queen’s Park - just a stone’s throw from campus - were encouraged to do so. So, many of us did- joining the crowds to return to the conference later in the afternoon.

The city was a-buzz with thousands upon thousands streaming into the Queen’s Park area. Folks of all ages gathered to voice their concerns about the climbing and alarming climate crisis that is plaguing many people around the planet both geographically and psychologically. Image courtesy of Defne Inceoglu.
In keeping up with the themes of both the conference, the conversations around museum risk-taking, climate change and the future action (or inaction) of museums, I had the opportunity to invite alumnus Douglas Worts to join in and speak with me briefly on these very poignant issues.

Image courtesy of Defne Inceoglu.
A bit about Worts:

Worts graduated the Museum Studies program in 1982, going on to work at the AGO as an Educator in the Adult Programs department. Worts introduced the practice of integrated audience research into the exhibit development process – with a focus on exploring experimental interpretive strategies. Through his work, he became a founding member of the US-based Visitor Studies Association. In 1997, his focus shifted from individual visitors to how museums could help catalyze meaningful cultural impacts and adaptation in a fast-changing world – specifically related to local/global sustainability.

Worts’ current project is WorldViews Consulting as a culture and sustainability expert. Worts also consults on the ‘Sustainability Task Force’ for the American Association for State and Local History. Read Worts’ full bio here.

I: You attended the climate strike in Toronto. Can you speak a bit about your experience during this strike? What were some positive things you took away from this?

W: The enthusiasm of the youth leaders and their willingness to step up and become voices in this moment, has been inspiring to me. Joining in the march was pretty amazing! I had no idea how many tens of thousands of people were there - but there were lot of people! Part of me was thrilled to hear the chanting and singing and the strength that comes from large groups of people. I kept hearing the refrain “Climate Justice Now!” and I wondered, how many people in the crowd would be able to describe what that phrase meant to them. I knew that it was important that large numbers needed to make a loud noise.

A Google Maps screenshot of Queen's Park and College Street. The protestors shut down the roads and created congestion in the city; evidence of a massive turnout. Courtesy of Defne Inceoglu.

(con't)
But the next day, the leaders needed to be able to move forward with:

- An understanding of what Climate Justice actually requires
- The causes and impacts of current climate change trends
- The leverage points across our society where change must happen in order to affect the climate change trends (because these trends are symptoms of much larger, cultural dysfunction).

In my view the drivers of climate change, as well as social and economic inequity, are rooted deep in the values, behaviours and structures upon which our economic, social, political and legal systems are based. These are in fact the core of our cultural reality - and yet not even discussed by this thing we call the ‘cultural sector’. Given the global scale of existing museum networks, our sector has the ability to re-tool itself to become catalysts of cultural change and adaptation. And yet, this really doesn’t even seem to be on the table in museological circles.

Toronto Climate Strike. Image courtesy of Defne Inceoglu.

I: Going off of the theme of the Unconference, “risk-taking”, what do you feel is the most important, yet risky, change we must make in our institutions?

W: As for the idea of "risk" - there is altogether too much focus on 'risk-taking’ as an attribute of ‘excellence’. I certainly have witnessed directors talk about ‘risk’ as a brand characteristic. To me, this kind of thinking is mostly marketing hyperbole and a misunderstanding of the notion of risk. There are risks associated with absolutely everything.


At this point in time, the ‘risky’ behaviour is sticking with the status quo.

We know that human overconsumption, unconscious systems, greed, self-interest, wastefulness are all attributes of the status quo. Perhaps the most serious risk that museums can take is to remain committed to their three historical pillars - buildings, collections and exhibits. It seems so obvious to me that buildings, collections and exhibits are strategies in the service of catalyzing public value. Yet few museums truly plan for, or measure, the catalyzing of public value. I see this absence of planning as being risky behaviour, because the potential for negative consequences is very high.

Museums, for me, embody the potential for generating ‘the place of the muses’, which is not fundamentally a physical place - but a psychological and social space. The muses belong everywhere where our living culture is playing it self out hopefully in adaptive ways. Risk must be consciously calculated in order to maximize the potential for adaptive impacts and minimize non-adaptive impacts. Risk assessment is fundamental and central to what all parts of our society must be doing. Museums could be helping to catalyze these processes across society, but it will require significant internal transformation of the historical and existing assumptions about the core goals, activities, and measures of success of museums.

What are some other things you would like Musings readers to know about you?

I taught Museum Education in the MMSt program from about 1991 to 1996 and have been guest lecturing in the program across my entire career. In 2014, I had the honour of being the first Research Fellow in Museum Studies at the Georgia O’Keeffe Museum Research Center in Santa Fe, New Mexico.
_

The future of the museums' role in participating in, teaching and pursuing climate action is a sentiment that must be pushed further than our current efforts as museum professionals. It will not be easy, it will not be quick and it will not be without growing pains and resistance. However, we can now see the public, our potential and probable audiences, rallying all over the world for action. Is this the sign of change to come? Can we begin to pick up the pieces of what needs to be fixed, or should we rebuild it all together? Keeping these important questions in our minds as we go forward will be paramount to the ability to incite real institutional change. The challenge will be, as Worts mentioned, internal transformations to our mandates, missions and values that will reflect response versus reflection.


This interview has been edited for length and clarity.

22 July 2019

THE GHOSTS IN COLLECTIONS: WHAT TO DO WHEN YOU COME ACROSS SOMETHING YOU CAN’T EXPLAIN

Collections Corner | Defne Inceoglu

Boo! Illustration by Defne Inceoglu.
Picture this:

It’s evening, nearing 7 PM. Your colleagues have left for the night. You are staying, having decided to work late into the night. A new donation has arrived and you are eager to sort through it and describe before the start of the weekend.

You are unsure if there is still daylight at the surface, you are not sure if anyone remains. You sit below ground in the collections room of your institution.

The security guards must still be roaming the galleries, you reassure yourself.

You suddenly hear a gentle ‘thunk,’ coming out from the shelves that sit behind you. You seize up, breaking into goosebumps. You take a deep breath and close your eyes. Cautiously, you slowly take the time to look around to investigate. You spot something peculiar! A box has been left there in the middle of the aisle.

Getting up from your seat, you make your way gingerly towards the box. Cautiously kneeling down, you place your hands on the lid to pop it open. You hesitate for a moment, feeling fear swelling into your chest. Shaking it off, you pull off the lid.

You are suddenly overwhelmed by the contents of the box. It is filled with hundreds of black and white photographs. They are loose, of varying sizes. Negatives and prints are all mixed up together. Hundreds of small, smiling faces are looking up at you. You begin to pick up individual images, flipping the prints over to inspect. The backs are left blank; no information, no handwriting, no numbers, no dates. You grab handfuls of photographs, throwing your head back, yelling,

“Where did you come from!? Who did this!?”
_________________________________________

What a nightmare!

As we chug along in our roles in collections, we will always encounter objects we cannot explain. This is especially true in smaller institutions, when catalogs are not quite complete. Perhaps somewhere along the line the information was lost, displaced. Sometimes, things are incorrectly labelled or dated. Other times, things can be a total mystery. It is an important note to keep in mind that we are only able to work within our capacities and the capacity of our institutions. We must always work to the best of our abilities, and sometimes mysteries are left unsolved.

How do we begin to navigate the scary world of the unknown? Follow along, as I show you some mysterious objects in the collection I work with and some starting points on how to identify.

Stay calm! Work slowly!

First thing’s first. Do not let the work (or amount of work) overwhelm you. You cannot know the answer to everything. Try to be logical in the steps you take. Never rush or you may just end up making assumptions and mislabelling or misdating objects. Take care to do the research.

Yes, here are some cute little pictures in frames. Where did you come from?! Who brought you here?! Photograph courtesy of Defne Inceoglu.
Investigate!

Look to the object(s) for help. Investigate any markings, writing or possible identifiers. This may also be a good moment to start a list of descriptions and best-guesses. Photograph the object(s). Look through your institution’s catalog or equivalent for any keywords or similarities to other objects in the collection that can offer more information.

Look! This one is signed. Perhaps a bit of preliminary Googling will bring up something promising. Photograph courtesy of Defne Inceoglu.
Back track!

Speak with colleagues and supervisors. Ask if they remember the object(s) coming in, if they remember who donated it or if they can aid with identifying it. Go through old emails, letters and files to see if anything has been kept about the provenance of the object.

Ask for help outside of the institution!

It is always a productive method to seek help outside of your own institution. Email local archives, historical associations or other museums with photographs of your mystery work. Sometimes people may recognize things you cannot.

Some sort of lamp, found tucked away, unlabelled, in a box. An email to other institutions would be helpful to help identify this one. Photograph courtesy of Defne Inceoglu.
Look to external resources!

Do some independent research. See if you can locate similar objects online or in other museum’s online resources. Consult other publications on collections management and see if they provide any sound advice.

What steps do you take to help identify mysterious objects?

26 June 2019

THE EVIDENCE OF A BIRD, THE ONCE-ALIVE BIRD: CONTEMPLATIONS FROM THE COLLECTIONS SPACE


Illustration by Defne Inceoglu.
Within this collections room I sit; it is cold. The light is dully reflected off of rows and rows of large storage containers and cabinets, each labelled carefully with the species names of the ones they contain. If you peeked inside you would see them all, laying down dutifully.

A cabinet. (Source: author).

I am here because I am researching a gallery which sits nearby, in this same building. I have been brought into this room, like I have in the past, the Ornithology department at the Royal Ontario Museum. I think now of the little feathers, row by row, drawer by drawer.

I am the first visitor of the day. (Source: author).

What is an animal, in a collection? What is a bird, to a collection? A collection is of course, a gathering or storing of things or objects. They are usually put together as alike or respondent. They do exist, over time, carefully kept away from light and heat. They are meant to stay put. We see the evidence of their existence too, they live in these spaces. Cabinets of small bodies are sewed and stuffed into their drawers. They are kept here to be remembered, studied, mounted, shown and taught. The bird, now an object of study for us.

I think about a pile of cards I saw near the back of the room. Groupings and stacks of birdwatching notes, filled out, dutifully. Each little pen mark and scribble marking down the evidence of a bird once seen. They remember the date, the time, the temperature of the day. I count the dozens of lines, compared to the hundreds of cards. The card I held was filled out by a man from Oshawa, out on a nice day watching birds in Durham. Each little line he makes with his pen is with intention; he is vigilant and careful. What is a card, or a line, to a bird?

These things float through my mind as I quietly sift through the folders of paperwork, evidence given to me to study. I look at the plans they had made for these animals to move up into the gallery. They are calcified into their natural poses, described by habitat; grouped in with their fellows.

Turning my head to look down the aisle. (Source: author).
I close up the folders and stack them neatly in order. I am tired from reading and note taking. I lean back in my chair and turn my head to look down the aisle. I study the towering yellow cabinets. I hear people walk by out in the hall, their chattering conversations carry into the room. I am not really alone in here, however.

The objects here collected were once-alive. This is complicated. It would be unwise of me to refer to these as just an object. They hold onto the likeness of the life it was, even now they are identifiable held up against the alive one. But what would any of this mean to a bird, anyways?

And now as I write this, I can hear the sounds of birds chirping outside. I think to myself, that all of my life I have lived with this sound. In the morning it signals to me that we are all in fact still around. They are here, just as we are.

3 June 2019

RISKING COLLECTIONS, RISKING COMMUNITY, RISKING DEFEAT: THE FATE OF RODMAN HALL ART CENTRE

Collections Corner | Defne Inceoglu

Rodman Hall Art Centre, St. Catharines, Ontario. (Source).

As a young, impressionable undergraduate student not too many years ago, I had the very incredible opportunity to attend courses at, write for (and visit religiously) Rodman Hall Art Centre. This 100-plus year old heritage house-turned-art-gallery is lauded internationally as a state of the art, National Level gallery (after the installation of a sophisticated collections vault and contemporary gallery space). Many mid-career artists exhibit their work in this space, alongside students who host yearly exhibitions. Purchased by Brock University in 2003 (for the low, low price of $2, plus the cost of liabilities!), the building has acted as both a professional exhibition space, teaching centre and learning space for students and other folks alike.

Screenshot from Brock University's 2003 agreement with Rodman Hall, Page 9. I wasn't kidding when I said they paid $2 for the building. Agreement made available through the Rodman Hall Alliance, full PDF available here.

The gallery regularly hosts travelling contemporary exhibits; however, it additionally holds a substantial permanent collection. Their website states that they hold over 1,000 objects, including a 2012 donation of 40 photographs by Edward Burtynsky from the artist himself. Other notable artists include Karel Appel, Tony Tascona and the Group of Seven. The value of this collection has not been disclosed; however, it can be assumed that it lies well over a million dollars. Located just outside of the City of St. Catharines’ downtown core, I hold many fond memories of happily walking, seeing the building on the horizon and knowing I got to spend time somewhere special. This feeling is echoed throughout the community it serves, where Rodman’s staff consistently provides fantastic programming.

As I entered my final years at Brock, there began to circulate a vicious rumour. The rumour sounded something like: "Brock University is ending their 20-year contractual commitment to fund and run Rodman Hall. The university is moving the permanent collection and handing over the heritage house to another organization." The faculty, student body and community were in shock. Members of the community banded together to petition against the University to rethink their decision. As time passed and I graduated, word got quiet about the fate of Rodman Hall’s collection.

In April 2019, news came forward from Brock in the way of a press release. To paraphrase, it was a confusing sort of… "here’s what we’re going to do with the collection and how we are going to it." The University had proposed to relocate the collection into another Brock owned building downtown, into a “class-A certified storage and display place at Brock’s Marilyn I. Walker School and Fine and Performing Arts (MIWSFPA) in downtown St. Catharines." While this is fine, dandy and idyllic, the reality is that the MIWSFPA building does not currently have a “class-A certified storage." Canadian Art tackled this conflict, writing, “the university also promises 2,000 square feet of new gallery space in the School of Fine and Performing Arts building, and a new 7,000-square-foot creative hub downtown, but hasn’t yet detailed how that will happen or be funded”. This head-scratching, ‘who’s gonna pay’ sort of puzzle is echoed in Brock’s statement, which reads,

“The plan is based on commitments that would give the local arts community expanded space and long-term stability in modern, climate-controlled facilities that are conducive to storing and showing works of art, this despite the University needing to find more than $15 million in budget savings after the province announced tuition cuts on Jan. 17 [2019]”.

A view of the MIWSFPA. (Source). 

Also consider the breaking of the community’s trust; the gallery’s donors will perhaps not be very pleased to find out that their objects are not being held in good faith. Donors who relied on the gallery’s Class-A designation to keep the collections safe now face as much uncertainty as the rest of us.

With the closing date approaching, 2023, how will Brock University be held accountable for building a new facility to protect Rodman Hall’s collection? Who will manage it? Who will display it? Meanwhile, large renovations and builds are happening on the main campus-massive construction projects. These have been stretching on for years, dominating the landscape with glass, concrete, dust and noise.

It almost feels like a cliche at this point, universities shutting down Humanities department’s resources. It is a tough reality to face, an institution like Brock overlooking the basic care and reputation of a historic collection in a bid to leave a contract. They are risking a lot, but upmost they are risking their relationship with their communities, especially the strong community that Rodman Hall helped to foster in Niagara.

If you want to learn more, please visit Rodman Hall Alliance, they provide a number of resources. There is also a petition if you’d like to sign it.