Showing posts with label deaccessioning. Show all posts
Showing posts with label deaccessioning. Show all posts

28 November 2019

FEMINIZING COLLECTIONS? LOOKING AT WOMEN'S PLACES IN ART COLLECTIONS IN TORONTO AND BEYOND

She's My Muse | Joanna Wreakes




Wall text from Mickalene Thomas: Femmes Noir at the AGO this past winter. Photo courtest of Joanna Wreakes.

Recently, the Baltimore Art Museum has made headlines for this announcement - they will only acquire work by women artists in 2020. The decision came following the disappointing results of the survey done by artnet News, which showed only 11% of all acquisitions and 14% of exhibitions at 26 prominent American museums over the past decade were works by female artists. These stats get even worse when we consider intersectionality - African American woman artists made up only 3.3% of the women artists who's works were acquired by these American institutions (source)

Disappointing but not surprising, right?

Accurate depiction of me reading the artnet survey results. Source.
The director of the Baltimore Art Museum, Christopher Bedford, addressed the announcement with this quote: “You don’t purchase one painting by a female artist of color and hang it on the wall next to a painting by Mark Rothko. To rectify centuries of imbalance, you have to do something radical.” On top of this collections decision, the Baltimore Art Museum is also focusing the exhibition programming on women artists and women-centric exhibitions.

Guerrilla Girls’ Do Women Have to be Naked to Get into the Met. Museum? (ca. 1989). Source.
This got me thinking, what are local institutions here in Toronto doing to address this imbalance?


Exhibition view of Femmes Noir at the AGO.
Photo courtesy of Joanna Wreakes.


In the spring of 2019 the AGO announced that they would be deaccessioning and auctioning off 20 works by Group of Seven member A.Y. Jackson. This caused enough of a stir in the public that the CBC actually published an article explaining deaccessioning and some reasons why the practice is carried out by museums and cultural institutions - it’s a great read for anyone who’s not familiar with the practice! The article also quotes curator of Canadian and Indigenous Art, Georgiana Uhlyarik discussing what the AGO would do with the money from auctioning off these pieces - it is designated for the purchase of new works for the Canadian and Indigenous collection. Ideally, these new purchases will reflect a more diverse collection for the AGO with works by women and particularly women of colour, but only time will tell.




I am hopeful that the AGO is on their way to including more women in both their permanent collection and feature exhibitions though. Last year the gallery hosted the first large-scale solo exhibition in Canada by American Artist Mickalene Thomas - Mickalene Thomas: Femmes Noirs. Currently, there are two feature exhibitions showing the work of local and international women artists - Hito Steyerl: This is the Future and Sandra Brewster: Blur. Never mind the recent acquisition of “Let’s Survive Forever”, an iconic infinity room by Japanese artist Yayoi Kusama.

Results of the survery undertaken by artnet News and In Other Words. Source.

Just a few blocks north of the AGO, the Gardiner Museum is also putting a focus on women artists. This month the International Ceramic Art Fair focused on showcasing “outstanding Canadian women-identified artists”. Also currently on display in the museum’s lobby is Kali Spitzer: Sister (in conjunction with Cannupa Hanska Luger: Every One). The two works address the crisis of missing and murdered Indigenous women, girls, queer, and trans community members.

What examples have you seen here in Toronto (and beyond!) of feminizing museum collections? What is the next step museum professionals and visitors alike can take to continue to address this inequality in our collections and programming?

13 December 2018

RISING TIDES, SWELLING COLLECTIONS

Museums on Earth | Jordan Fee


For the past two weeks, an image has sprung up in my mind. I imagine the Royal Ontario Museum during a flood. Correction: I imagine the ROM during the flood, the one that is creeping up on us as I write this article. I imagine basements and storage rooms filled to the brim with water and objects, taxidermied animals being thrust forth from the depths of the museum, and spilling out into the main halls. Perhaps this would be another chance for the museum to discover yet another long-lost dinosaur skeleton.

Gordo, the Borasaurus discovered in 2007 at the ROM. Source.
This vision began after I started to look into the connections between waste, sustainability, climate change, and museums. A professor had assigned our class some readings on museum collections – one of them was a chapter from Active Collections, a book that explores how many museums are being “held hostage” by their massive, cumbersome collections. You can read the Active Collections manifesto on their website, and there you can also explore the different resources, case studies and “crazy ideas” that they are attempting to promote in the museological world.

"Stop...The Collections Avalanche!" Source.
The chapter that we read dealt mainly with the notion of assessing museum objects for their value to society, rather than simply acquiring them for the sake of doing so. This sentiment also is echoed in the Active Collections manifesto:

“There’s little point in preserving collections if they don’t actively support the mission. We believe collections must either advance the mission or they must go.”

In most cases, museums don’t even know what their storage rooms contain – the article about the ROM that I mentioned earlier shows this, but similar stories could probably be found at all levels of the museum world. The fact is that museums – and history museums, in particular – are becoming hoarder houses. In an article titled "Museums and Sustainability", published by the journal Cultural Trends in 2008, Nick Merriman notes that most museum professionals “were unwilling to embark on programmes of rationalization until they had greater knowledge of their collections through documentation initiatives.” However, to gain full knowledge of their collections would in most cases take years and years. In that time, the museum would most likely continue the annual 1-2% growth in their collections, thereby extending the improbability that such a task could ever be accomplished. When I mentioned this fact to my professor, he noted with a grin that these people are not museum professionals–instead, they are addicts.

What might this addiction say about the future of museums? To be perfectly honest, it saddens me that so little has been done to confront this issue. Clearly most museum professionals are aware of this problem. Many museums across the world acknowledge their lack of storage, and yet these same museums continue to house more and more objects. The fact is that sometime this century, many museums across the world will come face to face with the realities of climate change.

Hurricane Sandy spelled catastrophe for a number of New York City’s museums and galleries, and this storm was by no means an anomaly. Storms like this will continue to occur around the world, with increasing frequency, for the rest of our lives. We can develop new preservation techniques to combat them, but one day these disasters will overwhelm our abilities. Nature always does. Here, I think it is fitting to include a quote from a gallery worker from New York responding to the storm that swept up so many artworks:

     “We prepared, but the amount of water that came in was above all the highest estimates.”

At the risk of sounding melodramatic, I must say that this is only a tepid sign of what’s to come.

"Hurricane Sandy Flooding East Village 2012." Source.
Recently, in my free time, I have been reading A Song For a Blue Ocean by Carl Safina, which examines the destruction of tuna fisheries across the world. In this book, Safina provides details on a wide variety of conferences, meetings and debates between government officials, conservationists and recreational fishers about what should be done to halt the rapid decrease in tuna populations. In each and every case, absolutely nothing is achieved that might realistically slow or stay the decline. Quotas are cut in half, yet are quickly restored. The conversation exists, but action is never taken.

Just as fishing corporations and recreationalists have a historically unhealthy relationship with tuna,  museums have an unhealthy relationship with objects. As many articles on the subject of deaccessioning state, what museums are doing is the very antithesis of sustainability. Museums stack up objects in decrepit, unkempt storage rooms until one day they can hand it off. To who?

To us.

We inherit the world that generations before us have created. We also inherit the collections that these professionals have been collecting. What matters now is what we choose to do with them. Do we continue on this Sisyphisian quest towards creating comprehensive museums, or do we take real action to change our collecting practices? Ultimately, this is not simply a question of objects; it is a question of how we perceive material culture in a world affected by climate change. Collections have a massive carbon footprint, and while deaccessioning objects may only make a tiny, tiny dent in our flawed environmental practices, it would nevertheless serve as a statement of acceptance.

"Flooded Piazza San Marco in Venice." Source.
Acceptance of what, might you ask? Acceptance of the fact that collections are meaningless if they are hidden away. Acceptance of the fact that the world will wait no longer. A flood will one day take place in our backyard, and in various backyards across the world. Perhaps we should engage in some extreme measures of preventative conservation and begin a drastic program of deaccessioning. What good is an object if it sits, unseen by the public, in a poorly kept storage space? I can only hope that something will be done with these collections before a storm like Hurricane Sandy hits Toronto.

If you’d like to read more about which areas of the world are at risk of flooding, here is an insightful article from Der Speigel. While I understand that this is not necessarily the cheerful kind of content that people look for at this time of the year, I do find it necessary to improve our understanding of future implications for the museum world. Happy holidays, everyone! I'll see you all in the new year.

7 May 2018

A DEACCESSIONING DRAMA AT THE NATIONAL GALLERY OF CANADA

MUSE NEWS

BY: AMY INTRATOR

Welcome to a new term of Musings and a brand new column! To kick off our Summer 2018 season, I am introducing Muse News, a column that will explore some of the biggest headlines in museum news worldwide. By taking a closer look at some of these stories, I hope to discover how current developments explain, or even complicate, trends in museum studies.

In the first edition of Muse News I am exploring the recent debacle surrounding the National Gallery of Canada and the sale of Marc Chagall’s La Tour Eiffel (1929). For over a month, the impending sale of this artwork has captured the attention of audiences worldwide and raised serious questions about the Gallery’s deaccessioning processes. I will provide a brief timeline of the unfolding drama.

Exterior of the National Gallery of Canada. Source.

It all started with a press release. On March 20th, 2018, Christie’s, one of the leading art auction houses, announced the upcoming sale of Chagall’s La Tour Eiffel. This painting belongs to the National Gallery of Canada, and the press release announced that the sale of the painting, estimated worth between US $6 million to $9 million, would benefit the Gallery’s Acquisition Fund.

Media outlets and galleries worldwide quickly caught wind of the news that this extremely valuable painting was leaving Canada. The backlash came from all directions. Some were enraged about the sale of the painting. Others were shocked by the lack of transparency in deaccessioning processes at the Gallery, as the public was only hearing about this sale once the decision was finalized.

Amidst the outcry, Marc Mayer, the director and CEO of the National Gallery of Canada, defended the sale. In an interview with CBC, Mayer revealed that the money from the sale of the Chagall painting would be used to acquire a piece of art deemed more significant and unique to the collection. The identity of the painting remained a mystery.

In an April 16th letter, Mayer confirmed that the Gallery intended to acquire Saint Jerome Hears the Trumpet of the Last Judgement, painted by Jacques-Louis David in 1779.

Jacques-Louis David's Saint Jerome Hears the Trumpet of the Last Judgement (1779). Source.

Mayer’s April 16th letter detailed the history of the painting, which has been in Canada since 1917. The letter explained the Gallery’s desire to protect the painting from leaving the country amidst interest from foreign buyers. Mayer’s message concluded, however, that the sale of the Chagall would proceed even if the Gallery did not purchase the David painting “as per the rigorous de-accession process.”

In an open letter from the National Gallery of Canada published on April 23rd, the Gallery continued to clarify the circumstances surrounding the sale of the Chagall work. The Gallery stated an openness to loaning the David painting to other Canadian galleries, but ultimately confirmed the decision to proceed with the sale of La Tour Eiffel.

Also on April 23rd, a surprising statement from Marie Montpetit, Minister of Culture and Communications and Minister responsible for the Protection and Promotion of the French Language: David’s Saint Jerome will be protected as Quebec heritage and it will remain in the province.

On April 26th, a final open letter from the Gallery stated that in light of the Government of Quebec’s decision to protect the David painting, the Chagall painting will no longer be sold and will remain in the national collection.

In some regards, this dramatic saga has a perfect conclusion: not one, but two masterpieces will remain in Canada, but looming questions darken this happily-ever-after. One of the largest questions that remains: how did the National Gallery manage to acquire an export permit for the Chagall painting?

I hope that this tale lives on as more than gallery gossip. The public became involved in a gallery’s deaccessioning decision, and ultimately the public voice helped reverse an all but finalized deal. The drama highlights the growing demand for transparency in museum operations and more inclusive governance structures that give the nation a voice in matters of national heritage.