Showing posts with label Chantelle Perreault. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Chantelle Perreault. Show all posts

1 March 2021

LAND ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS: MEANING AND ACTION

 Breaking the Glass Case | Chantelle Perreault


I have lived in Canada all of my life – in big cities like Toronto and Ottawa, and in suburban towns like Whitby, Ontario – and in all of these instances, I have been culpable of knowing far too little about the Indigenous history of the land I was occupying.

Kanyon Sayers-Roods, a Mutsun Ohlone activist, affirms that "there have always been Indigenous peoples in the spaces we call home, and there always will be". All land in Canada, from coast to coast to coast, has Indigenous connections, and the increasing practice of Land Acknowledgments provides an opportunity for settlers to gain an introductory understanding about past and present Indigenous relationships to this territory. While the practice of acknowledging connections to both the land and the people who reside on it is not new – this has been a tradition amongst many Indigenous cultures long before the arrival of European settlers, and Karyn Recollet, an urban-Cree professor at the University of Toronto, describes it as “an ancient practice that flows into the future” – today, organisations and individuals alike are engaging in the practice of crafting Land Acknowledgements more frequently.

Land Acknowledgments – intentional statements that recognise the relationships between Indigenous people and their traditional land – act to remind settlers of a place’s Indigenous history and the continued presence of Indigenous people in that place today, and encourage settlers to understand how they have come to live on this land, explains Indigenous U of T. You may have heard a Land Acknowledgement spoken aloud at an event, or read one in a syllabus at school. Museums and heritage institutions, in an effort to reconcile their own colonial roots, are also increasingly turning towards the use of Land Acknowledgements.

The process of creating the Land Acknowledgment and the content included in the statement are equally important aspects of the practice. The Native Governance Centre explains that, as a settler, it is essential to begin with self-reflection and an understanding of the goals of Land Acknowledgements — specific goals can differ depending on the institution, but should include the empowerment of Indigenous voices and a commitment to ongoing action. Before beginning, knowledge of the land you are occupying and the Indigenous groups that reside there (historically and presently) is crucial, and this will require research and time. Anishinaabe academic Sheila Cote-Meek also emphasises the importance of connecting with Indigenous people of the territory when possible (and with proper compensation for labour).

The language of Land Acknowledgments is significant: the use of present tense rather than historical references to Indigenous communities reiterates that Indigenous people continue to live on this territory today — colonialism is an ongoing process. 

Land Acknowledgement from the website of the Royal Ontario Museum

Similarly, when Land Acknowledgments are read aloud, accurate pronunciation is required: Emily Riddle of Alexander First Nation in Treaty 6 territory explains that mispronunciation indicates “a lack of effort and consideration” by the organisation. An emphasis on correct pronunciation can be encouraged by including a pronunciation guide, as seen in the City of Toronto’s official Land Acknowledgement.

Pronunciation guide from the City of Toronto's Land Acknowledgment webpage

Land Acknowledgements should also be accompanied by further action – these statements are not made to "check a box", but stem from a commitment to empower Indigenous voices. The Manitoba Museum, following their Land Acknowledgement, lists a series of further commitments towards reconciliation, such as developing collaborative relationships with Indigenous communities and partnering with local communities to share more Indigenous stories. This transparency encourages accountability and makes clear to the museum’s audience that they are committed to specific goals when it comes to reconciliation.

We Are All Treaty People, exhibit at the Manitoba Museum. (Image: manitobamuseum.ca)

Museums often have a colonial past to reckon with, and have a responsibility to understand their connection to the physical land that they occupy. Anishinaabe writer and educator Hayden King reminds us that Land Acknowledgements are not done to validate Canadian presence on the land, but rather to empower and uplift the voices of Indigenous people. At a time where Land Acknowledgements are becoming increasingly common, and can sometimes seem redundant or meaningless, museums have an obligation to reflect on the purposes of these statements, and how they will impact museum practices going forward.

1 February 2021

RECOGNIZING RIBBON SKIRTS: CLOTHING AS CULTURAL HERITAGE

 Breaking the Glass Case | Chantelle Perreault


Last December, 10-year old Saskatchewan student Bella Kulak, of Cote First Nation, was criticised by a teaching aid for wearing a ribbon skirt to her school’s Formal Day: the ribbon skirt, an item of traditional clothing within multiple Indigenous communities, was not recognised by the school employee as appropriate for the event. When Kulak’s story was shared online by a family member, the student received an outpouring of support, both from within her community and across Canada. Supporters posted images of themselves in their own ribbon skirts, displaying pride in their traditions and demonstrating that there is an important connection between material culture and heritage. 

The wearing of a ribbon skirt, both as an everyday garment and as ceremonial attire, is a tradition that spans many Indigenous communities in Canada. As noted by the Milwaukee Public Museum, when Europeans arrived in North America, woven fabrics and ribbons were used to trade with Indigenous people, and they used these materials to create a variety of symbolic items, including the ribbon skirt.

Ribbon Skirt in the collection of the National Museum of the American Indian, acquired 1950 (catalogue no. 21/4934)

Ribbon skirts are made with a unique process of applique, wherein ribbons of diverse colours are sewn onto a base fabric, using methods of cutting and folding to create patterns. This practice of ribbon-work began in the late 19th century in the Great Lakes region, eventually moving westward towards the prairies and increasing in prominence. However, coinciding with community displacement and assimilation efforts, the practice began to lose popularity in the late 19th century. In the first half of the 20th century, museums increasingly began to acquire and display ribbon-work and today museums across North America have ribbon skirts within their collections.

The practice of ribbon-work re-emerged in the second half of the 20th century, alongside Indigenous cultural resurgence movements and Indigenous activism movements, specifically in western Canada. Ribbon skirts can come in a variety of forms, some more simple and some more elaborate, incorporating many different colours and motifs. The colours of the ribbons used can convey symbolism, reflecting ties to nature and land, or to political movements and initiatives such as Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls (MMIWG). Today, ribbon skirt teachings and customs can vary from community to community, and colours and motifs can indicate diverse meanings. 


Clothing acts as an important connection to one’s cultural heritage and identity. As noted by Seneca College News, it can demonstrate a connection to family and ancestry, and it can give the wearer feelings of safety and security. The ribbon skirt is an example of the connection between clothing and heritage, and reminds us that the items we see in museums exist not only within their museum context, but within a community context as well. 

4 November 2020

COLONIAL HERITAGE: EXPLORING KNOWLEDGE ORGANISATION SYSTEMS WITHIN MUSEUMS

 Breaking the Glass Case | Chantelle Perreault



All museums have standardised systems of knowledge organisation. Record-keeping practices, thesauri, and classification systems such as nomenclature are just a few examples; these standardise the ways in which information is recorded and understood. To some extent, all museums rely on pre-defined categories for knowledge organisation, and this shapes the way we think about the objects they keep in their collections. 

A display at Le Musée des Abénaki in Quebec | Source

When it comes to standardising knowledge, scholar Hannah Turner notes that the creation of a knowledge organisation system is a “world-building exercise” in which certain narratives are overlooked in favour of others. While all knowledge frameworks must have defined boundaries, this is an important consideration to keep in mind when thinking about how we interpret objects from a museum’s collection; whose voice is included, and whose is excluded?

Many museum classification systems are based in colonial practices, and so in many instances, the colonial roots of a museum impact the manner in which records were historically categorised. Sandra Littletree, a Diné/Eastern Shoshone professor at the University of Washington’s Information School, along with Zuni/Tlingit professor Miranda Belard-Lewis and Arizona State University professor Marisa Duarte, note that colonialism has been paramount in shaping the practices of knowledge organisation. Colonial collections within museums, as noted by Turner, often began as a study of “otherness” — encounters with cultures and peoples that were considered to be “unknown”. Several events in the 19th century — such as the development of the natural sciences and the theory of evolution, the advancement of anthropology, and the increase in ethnographic collecting practices — affected how heritage items were collected, interpreted, and classified. In some instances, the act of ordering and classifying itself can be connected to relationships of power, and so it is important to consider the institutional goals of categorisation, and whose voice is being heard.

The field of Indigenous Knowledge Organisation (IKO) emerged with the goal of decolonising Eurocentric approaches to knowledge organisation. As noted by Littletree et al., there are “fundamental ontological differences between western oriented systems of knowledge and Indigenous ways of knowing”. She defined IKO as “the methodologies and means by which Native and Indigenous peoples create protocols to cohere, name, articulate, collate, and make accessible objects that indicate Indigenous knowledge” – this emerged in contrast to the colonial history of knowledge organisation.

Rather than an attempt to reform existing knowledge organisation practices, IKO is a “practice of liberation”, centering instead, as Littletree explains, the Indigenous experience as well as issues including self-determination and ethical access to knowledge. The Eurocentric approach to knowledge organisation is not the only approach, and often it does not reflect the whole story of non-Eurocentric objects.

As sites of knowledge production and knowledge dissemination, museums have a responsibility to consider the narratives that they are circulating. Critically thinking about the ways in which we interpret and categorise heritage items is a crucial step towards a more diligent system of knowledge organisation.